Theory’s Tone Deafness
This chapter describes the relevance, failures, and possibilities of music theory in a jail music program in which rap and hip-hop are the primary genres the largely African-American participants produce. Participants’ “ethnotheory” mediates the theoretical frameworks underlying the software they use and the theoretical concepts the author brings into the jail. The author asks how music theory might be more useful in carceral contexts, both in terms of its analytical perspectives and as a strategic legitimation of inmate’s expressions in an oppressive social context. The author interrogates the claim that academic arts programs in carceral contexts are often exploitative and that music theory in such contexts may represent a form of epistemic injustice. Finally, the chapter concludes with some suggestions on how academic music theorists might further the aims of social justice in carceral spaces.