In 1986, Beigel [Be87] (see also [Od89, III.5.9]) proved the nonspeedup theorem: if A, B ⊆ ω, and as a function of 2n variables can be computed by an algorithm which makes at most n queries to B, then A is recursive (informally, 2n parallel queries to a nonrecursive oracle A cannot be answered by making n sequential (or “adaptive”) queries to an arbitrary oracle B). Here, 2n cannot be replaced by 2n − 1. In subsequent papers of Beigel, Gasarch, Gill, Hay, and Owings the theory of “bounded query classes” has been further developed (see, for example, [BGGOta], [BGH89], and [Ow89]). The topic has also been studied in the context of structural complexity theory (see, for example, [AG88], [Be90], and [JY90]).If A ⊆ ω and n ≥ 1, let . Beigel [Be87] stated the powerful “cardinality conjecture” (CC): if A, B ⊆ ω, and can be computed by an algorithm which makes at most n queries to B, then A is recursive. Owings [Ow89] verified CC for n = 1, and, for n 1, he proved that A is recursive in the halting problem. We prove that CC is true for all n.
Computing functions with parallel queries to NP
