BACKGROUND
The recent article published on November 27 in 2020 is well-written but remains several questionable issues that are required to clarifications further, particularly for readers who hope to replicate this study using a longer period of months instead of the original days from March 11 to May 19, 2020.
OBJECTIVE
Redo the study using a longer period of time to examine the difference from and similarity to the previous study and present results using visual representations.
METHODS
Similar search schemes were compared to the golden standard(LitCovid) using three metrics of sensitivity, precision, and F-score. We applied similar search schemes to extract publications related to COVID-19 from January to November in Pubmed Central(PMC). The Kano model was applied to present the study results divided into three groups of high sensitivity, high precision, and neutral. Comparison of publication counts was made using the line plot to display.
RESULTS
We observed that the comprehensive search scheme recommended by the original authors was ranked at the third placement instead of the first one shown in this study. A small number of articles extracted from the PMC were attributable to the reasons for schemes with (1) only one keyword of coronavirus, (2) that totally constrained by Wuhan, and (3) that hyphen and space misused in keyword terms. Scheme 2, authored by Shokraneh in the journal of BMJ, was ranked first, followed by Schemes 9 and 1 with F-scores at 97.9, 90.2, and 87.3, respectively. The single-term search COVID-19 performed best in terms of precision (99.9%) but not well in terms of sensitivity (76.6%) and F-score (86.7%). The term Wuhan virus performed the worst: 24.2% for sensitivity, 90.9% for precision, and 138.2% for F-score due to the reason for using AND condition in the search string. All 32 schemes were compared and displayed on the Kano diagram.
CONCLUSIONS
Different results were displayed using similar search schemes with a longer period of time from January to November in 2020. Scheme 2 is recommended for the bibliometric study related to COVID-19 in the future. The Kano diagram can be a visual display to compare search schemes based on precision(on Axis X), sensitivity(on Axis Y), and F-score(by bubble size) laid on a dashboard.
CLINICALTRIAL
Nil