Ethos and Moral Education: Critical Comments on Virtue Ethics and Virtue Education

Author(s):  
Anton Hügli
2020 ◽  
pp. 105382592096703
Author(s):  
Paul Stonehouse

Background: The long-held assumption of character development through outdoor adventure education (OAE) maintains some adherents; however, growing criticism calls into question its efficacy. Yet, current social/environmental crises signal the immediate importance of moral education. Purpose: This article highlights the importance of character in moral assessment and guidance and registers the need for an account of character relevant to OAE’s social/environmental aims. It suggests a modern virtue ethical lens as a philosophical and practical way forward for OAE’s moral educational mission. Approach: This article searches the OAE literature for substantiating evidence (rational and empirical). Then, in light of this search, a virtue ethical account of character, including its development, and relevance to OAE, is outlined. Conclusions: Evidence for character development through OAE is nearly non-existent, and semantic, philosophical, and empirical critiques loom large. If OAE wishes to continue its moral mission, then an account of character—promisingly provided in virtue ethical theory(s)—that can withstand these critiques is needed. Implications: Applied to OAE, modern virtue ethical theory provides an account of character, copes with the critiques, and supplies socially/environmentally relevant curricular and pedagogical guidance for future practice, while likely delimiting our claim to character development.


Author(s):  
David Carr

This chapter explores key respects in which virtue ethics has been considered of relevance to education. First, much recent work has focused on the case for a broader virtue ethical understanding of the aims of education and schooling and on the prospect of conceiving moral education in terms of the cultivation of virtuous character. Second, many educational philosophers and theorists have sought a virtue ethical account of the practice of teaching and/or the professional role and responsibilities of career teachers. Third, however, much recent educational attention has been devoted to the virtues that Aristotle distinguished from moral virtues as epistemic virtues, with particular regard to their significance for the professional development of teachers, as well as for education more generally.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document