SynopsisAfter the detection of correlations in two coherent light beams by Hanbury Brown and Twiss, objections were raised by Brannen and Ferguson on the basis of the experiments of Adam, Janossy and Varga and their own experiments in which no correlations were detected. It is pointed out here that the different groups were looking for two entirely different effects, one being quadratic, the other one linear in the number of photons involved; the quadratic effect (discovered by Hanbury Brown and Twiss) is in agreement with quantum theory while the linear effect is not. It was shown by Purcell and by Hanbury Brown and Twiss that the choice of parameters in the experiments which gave negative results was inadequate to show the quadratic effect. It is shown in this paper that their experiments were also inadequate to decide between the existence or nonexistence of the linear effect.
Self-focusing threshold of Gaussian-elliptic light beams