Convergent evolution can provide insights into the predictability of, and constraints on, the evolution of biodiversity. One striking example of convergence is seen in the ‘river dolphins’. The four dolphin genera that make up the ‘river dolphins’ (Inia geoffrensis, Pontoporia blainvillei, Platanista gangetica and Lipotes vexillifer) do not represent a monophyletic group, despite being very similar in morphology. This has led many to using the ‘river dolphins’ as an example of convergent evolution. However, these morphological similarities have never been quantified. We investigate whether the skulls of the four ‘river dolphin’ genera are convergent when compared to other toothed dolphin taxa. We use geometric morphometrics to uncover shape variation in the skulls of the ‘river dolphins’ and then apply a number of phylogenetic techniques to test for convergence. We find significant convergence in the skull morphology of the ‘river dolphins’. The four genera seem to have experienced evolution in the same direction, leading to a convergent morphotype characterised by elongation of skull features. The cause of this morphological convergence remains unclear, but our results support hypotheses of shared feeding mode or diet and thus provide the foundation for future work into convergence within the Odontoceti.
Peer Review #1 of "Morphological convergence in ‘river dolphin’ skulls (v0.1)"
