Mixed Integer Programming vs. Logic-Based Benders Decomposition for Planning and Scheduling

Author(s):  
André Ciré ◽  
Elvin Coban ◽  
John N. Hooker
Author(s):  
Stephen J. Maher

AbstractA general enhancement of the Benders’ decomposition (BD) algorithm can be achieved through the improved use of large neighbourhood search heuristics within mixed-integer programming solvers. While mixed-integer programming solvers are endowed with an array of large neighbourhood search heuristics, few, if any, have been designed for BD. Further, typically the use of large neighbourhood search heuristics is limited to finding solutions to the BD master problem. Given the lack of general frameworks for BD, only ad hoc approaches have been developed to enhance the ability of BD to find high quality primal feasible solutions through the use of large neighbourhood search heuristics. The general BD framework of SCIP has been extended with a trust region based heuristic and a general enhancement for large neighbourhood search heuristics. The general enhancement employs BD to solve the auxiliary problems of all large neighbourhood search heuristics to improve the quality of the identified solutions. The computational results demonstrate that the trust region heuristic and a general large neighbourhood search enhancement technique accelerate the improvement in the primal bound when applying BD.


2020 ◽  
Vol 32 (2) ◽  
pp. 473-506 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tobias Achterberg ◽  
Robert E. Bixby ◽  
Zonghao Gu ◽  
Edward Rothberg ◽  
Dieter Weninger

Mixed integer programming has become a very powerful tool for modeling and solving real-world planning and scheduling problems, with the breadth of applications appearing to be almost unlimited. A critical component in the solution of these mixed integer programs is a set of routines commonly referred to as presolve. Presolve can be viewed as a collection of preprocessing techniques that reduce the size of and, more importantly, improve the “strength” of the given model formulation, that is, the degree to which the constraints of the formulation accurately describe the underlying polyhedron of integer-feasible solutions. As our computational results will show, presolve is a key factor in the speed with which we can solve mixed integer programs and is often the difference between a model being intractable and solvable, in some cases easily solvable. In this paper we describe the presolve functionality in the Gurobi commercial mixed integer programming code. This includes an overview, or taxonomy of the different methods that are employed, as well as more-detailed descriptions of several of the techniques, with some of them appearing, to our knowledge, for the first time in the literature.


2020 ◽  
Vol 54 (4) ◽  
pp. 897-919
Author(s):  
Ahmed Khassiba ◽  
Fabian Bastin ◽  
Sonia Cafieri ◽  
Bernard Gendron ◽  
Marcel Mongeau

The extended aircraft arrival management problem, as an extension of the classic aircraft landing problem, seeks to preschedule aircraft on a destination airport a few hours before their planned landing times. A two-stage stochastic mixed-integer programming model enriched by chance constraints is proposed in this paper. The first-stage optimization problem determines an aircraft sequence and target times over a reference point in the terminal area, called initial approach fix (IAF), so as to minimize the landing sequence length. Actual times over the IAF are assumed to deviate randomly from target times following known probability distributions. In the second stage, actual times over the IAF are assumed to be revealed, and landing times are to be determined in view of minimizing a time-deviation impact cost function. A Benders reformulation is proposed, and acceleration techniques to Benders decomposition are sketched. Extensive results on realistic instances from Paris Charles-de-Gaulle airport show the benefit of two-stage stochastic and chance-constrained programming over a deterministic policy.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document