AbstractMany studies have highlighted the potential of DNA-based methods for the biomonitoring of freshwater macroinvertebrates, however only a few studies have investigated homogenisation of bulk samples that include debris to reduce sample-processing time. In order to explore the use of DNA-based methods in water quality assessment in South Africa, this study compares morphological and molecular-based identification of freshwater macroinvertebrates at the mixed higher taxon and mOTU level while investigating abundance and comparing mOTU recovery with historical species records. From seven sites across three rivers in South Africa, we collected a biomonitoring sample, an intensive-search comprehensive sample and an eDNA sample per site. The biomonitoring sample was picked and scored according to standard protocols and the leftover debris and comprehensive samples were homogenised including all debris. DNA-based methods recovered higher diversity than morphology, but did not always recover the same taxa, even at the family level. Regardless of the differences in taxon scores, most DNA-based methods except some eDNA samples, returned the same water quality assessment category as the standard morphology-based assessment. Homogenised comprehensive samples recovered more freshwater invertebrate diversity than all other methods. The eDNA samples recovered 2 to 10 times more mOTUs than any other method, however 90% of reads were non-target and as a result eDNA recovered the lowest target diversity. However, eDNA did find some target taxa that the other methods failed to detect. This study shows that unsorted samples recover the same water quality scores as a morphology-based assessment and much higher diversity scores than both picked and eDNA samples. As a result, there is potential to integrate DNA-based approaches into existing metrics quickly while providing much more information for the development of more refined metrics at the species or mOTU level with distributional data which can be used for conservation and biodiversity management.
The relevance of diatoms for water quality assessment in South Africa: A position paper
