Open Reduction and Internal Fixation for Dorsal Fracture-dislocation of the Proximal Interphalangeal Joint

Purpose The purpose of this study was to investigate and compare the clinical and radiological results of ORIF with inter-fragment screw or buttress plate fixation of acute PIP joint fracture dorsal dislocation. Patients and Methods Between January 2007 to December 2016, nineteen patients – 14 men and 5 women with an average age of 40.9 (19 to 64) years – were included in this study; 9 patients underwent small sized interfragmentary screw fixation and 10 patients underwent small buttress plating. The average follow-up period was 45.1 (13 to 78) months. Clinical assessment included measurement of range of motion (ROM) of the proximal and distal interphalangeal joint (PIP, DIP), grip and pinch strength, and pain with use of the Visual Analog Scale (VAS). At the postoperative X-ray, articular step off, gap, and degree of dorsal subluxation was measured, and maintenance of the reduction, fracture union, and the presence of degenerative changes were assessed. Results All patients achieved solid unions without instability. The overall average range of motion of PIP joint were from 9° to 85° (10–83° in the screw group, 8–87° in the plate group without significant difference). However, the screw group (average: 53°) presented more flexion in the distal interphalangeal joint than the plate group (average: 34°). Plate fixation can cause limited DIP flexion. Six of the ten patients from the plate group, underwent implant removal and two of these patients required PIP joint arthrolysis due to the PIP flexion contracture of more than 30°. Three of the nine patients in screw group underwent implant removal and two of the three patients required PIP joint arthrolysis. Conclusion Mini plate and screw fixation of acute PIP joint fracture dorsal dislocation can achieve comparable favorable clinical and radiographic outcomes through stable fixation and early range of motion exercise. Screw fixation, if possible, is probably preferable to plate fixation because of better DIP joint ROM and lower incidence of hardware removal. If there is a need for plate fixation the use of a short plate is recommended to avoid joint stiffness.