Renaissance mass murder: civilians and soldiers during the Italian Wars

2020 ◽  
Vol 35 (2) ◽  
pp. 219-221
Author(s):  
Edward Muir
Keyword(s):  
Author(s):  
Stephen D. Bowd

Renaissance Mass Murder explores the devastating impact of war on the men and women of the Renaissance. In contrast to the picture of balance and harmony usually associated with the Renaissance, it uncovers in forensic detail a world in which sacks of Italian cities and massacres of civilians at the hands of French, German, Spanish, Swiss, and Italian troops were regular occurrences. The arguments presented are based on a wealth of evidence—histories and chronicles, poetry and paintings, sculpture and other objects—which together provide a new and startling history of sixteenth-century Italy and a social history of the Italian Wars. It outlines how massacres happened, how princes, soldiers, lawyers, and writers, justified and explained such events, and how they were represented in contemporary culture. On this basis the book reconstructs the terrifying individual experiences of civilians in the face of war and in doing so offers a story of human tragedy which redresses the balance of the history of the Italian Wars, and of Renaissance warfare, in favour of the civilian and away from the din of the battlefield. This book also places mass murder in a broader historical context and challenges claims that such violence was unusual or in decline in early modern Europe. Finally, it shows that women often suffered disproportionately from this violence and that immunity for them, as for their children, was often partially developed or poorly respected.


Author(s):  
Stephen D. Bowd
Keyword(s):  

The rhetoric of violence during the Italian Wars assumed different forms in the poetry, painting, chronicles, sculpture, and other objects which can be linked to war and mass murder. These rhetorical expressions drew on classical and scriptural precedents and were sometimes common to different textual genres, or crossed from one medium to another—for example from the print to the maiolica dish. Although the emotional range of such evidence appears quite muted in comparison with modern representations of war and violence, nevertheless Renaissance Italians were able to explore the experience of war by means of the ancient language of the passions, the dehumanization and objectification or enumeration of casualties, and through the potent lens of Christian martyrdom.


Author(s):  
Stephen D. Bowd

The fate of civilians during the Italian Wars (1494–1559) has sometimes been overshadowed by the historical attention paid to high politics, diplomacy, and military manoeuvres. A balanced picture of the Italian Wars ought to bring the experiences of civilians to the fore, and in this way help to illuminate broader debates about war and violence in the period after c.1450. The mass murder of civilians in the Italian Wars was a regular and significant event, which may be compared with the violence of subsequent conflicts, including the Thirty Years War (1618–48). This behaviour could be justified and often served a tactical or strategic goal, and it was far from being simply pathological or the expression of soldierly brutishness or northern barbarianism as it was presented by Francesco Guicciardini and other Italian observers.


2021 ◽  
Vol 17 ◽  
pp. 390
Author(s):  
Elli Papanikolaou
Keyword(s):  

Review of: Stephen D. Bowd, Renaissance Mass Murder: Civilians and Soldiers during the Italian Wars


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document