In this paper, for the sake of providing a concrete comparison between the usual Abbott–Deser–Tekin (ADT) formalism and its off-shell extension, as well as comparing the latter with the Barnich–Brandt–Compere (BBC) approach, we carry out these methods to compute the mass and angular momentum of the rotating charged Gödel black holes in five-dimensional minimal supergravity. We first present the off-shell ADT potential of the supergravity theories in arbitrary odd dimensions, which is consistent with the superpotential via the BBC approach. Then the off-shell generalized ADT method is applied to evaluate the mass and angular momentum of the Gödel-type black holes by including the contribution from the gauge field. Finally, we strictly obey the rules of the original ADT formalism to incorporate the contribution from the gauge field within the potential. With the help of the modified potential, we try to seek for appropriate reference backgrounds to produce the mass and angular momentum. It is observed that the ADT formalism has to incorporate the contribution from the matter fields to yield physical charges for the Gödel-type black holes.
Holographic duals of black holes in five-dimensional minimal supergravity
