scholarly journals The Fraternal Birth-Order Effect as Statistical Artefact: Convergent Evidence from Probability Calculus, Simulated Data, and Multiverse Meta- Analysis

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Johannes K Vilsmeier ◽  
Michael Kossmeier ◽  
Martin Voracek ◽  
Ulrich S. Tran
Keyword(s):  
Sexual Orientation ◽  
Birth Order ◽  
Meta Analysis ◽  
Order Effect ◽  
Probability Calculus ◽  
Older Brothers ◽  
Birth Order Effect ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order Effect ◽  
Ratio Variables

For a quarter of a century researchers investigating the origins of sexual orientation have largely ascribed to the fraternal birth order effect (FBOE) as a fact, holding that older brothers increase the odds of homosexual orientation among men through an immunoreactivity process. Here, we triangulate the empirical foundations of the FBOE from three distinct, informative perspectives: First, drawing on basic probability calculus, we deduce mathematically that the body of statistical evidence of the FBOE rests on the false assumptions that effects of family size should be controlled for and that this could be achieved through the use of ratio variables. Second, using a data-simulation approach, we demonstrate that by using ratio variables, researchers are bound to falsely declare corroborating evidence of an excess of older brothers at a rate of up to 100%, and that valid approaches attempting to quantify a potential excess of older brothers among homosexual men must control for the confounding effects of the number of older siblings. And third, we re-examine the empirical evidence of the FBOE by using a novel specification-curve and multiverse approach to meta-analysis. This yielded highly inconsistent and moreover similarly-sized effects across 64 male and 17 female samples (N = 2,778,998), compatible with an excess as well as with a lack of older brothers in both groups, thus, suggesting that almost no variation in the number of older brothers in men is attributable to sexual orientation.

scholarly journals BIRTH ORDER AND ANDROPHILIC MALE-TO-FEMALE TRANSSEXUALISM IN BRAZIL

2016 ◽  
Vol 49 (4) ◽  
pp. 527-535 ◽  
Author(s):  
Doug P. Vanderlaan ◽  
Ray Blanchard ◽  
Kenneth J. Zucker ◽  
Raffael Massuda ◽  
Anna Martha Vaitses Fontanari ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Sexual Orientation ◽  
Birth Order ◽  
Order Effect ◽  
Present Sample ◽  
Older Brothers ◽  
Birth Order Effect ◽  
Maternal Immune Hypothesis ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order Effect ◽  
Male To Female

SummaryPrevious research has indicated that biological older brothers increase the odds of androphilia in males. This finding has been termed thefraternal birth order effect. Thematernal immune hypothesissuggests that this effect reflects the progressive immunization of some mothers to male-specific antigens involved in fetal male brain masculinization. Exposure to these antigens, as a result of carrying earlier-born sons, is hypothesized to produce maternal immune responses towards later-born sons, thus leading to female-typical neural development of brain regions underlying sexual orientation. Because this hypothesis posits mechanisms that have the potential to be active in any situation where a mother gestates repeated male fetuses, a key prediction is that the fraternal birth order effect should be observable in diverse populations. The present study assessed the association between sexual orientation and birth order in androphilic male-to-female transsexuals in Brazil, a previously unexamined population. Male-to-female transsexuals who reported attraction to males were recruited from a specialty gender identity service in southern Brazil (n=118) and a comparison group of gynephilic non-transsexual men (n=143) was recruited at the same hospital. Logistic regression showed that the transsexual group had significantly more older brothers and other siblings. These effects were independent of one another and consistent with previous studies of birth order and male sexual orientation. The presence of the fraternal birth order effect in the present sample provides further evidence of the ubiquity of this effect and, therefore, lends support to the maternal immune hypothesis as an explanation of androphilic sexual orientation in some male-to-female transsexuals.

scholarly journals The association between the fraternal birth order effect in male homosexuality and other markers of human sexual orientation

2005 ◽  
Vol 1 (4) ◽  
pp. 393-395 ◽  
Author(s):  
Qazi Rahman
Keyword(s):  
Sexual Orientation ◽  
Birth Order ◽  
Order Effect ◽  
Sexually Dimorphic ◽  
Older Brothers ◽  
Birth Order Effect ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order ◽  
Psychological Gender ◽  
Male Sexual Orientation ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order Effect

Later fraternal birth order (FBO) is a well-established correlate of homosexuality in human males and may implicate a maternal immunization response in the feminization of male sexuality. This has led to the suggestion that FBO may relate to other markers of male sexual orientation which are robustly sexually dimorphic. If so, among homosexual males the number of older brothers should strongly correlate with traits such as spatial ability and psychological gender, indicative of greater behavioural feminization, compared to heterosexual males. The present study failed to find significant associations between number of older brothers and these traits.

THE CAUSE(S) OF THE FRATERNAL BIRTH ORDER EFFECT IN MALE HOMOSEXUALITY

2004 ◽  
Vol 36 (1) ◽  
pp. 51-59 ◽  
Author(s):  
WILLIAM H. JAMES
Keyword(s):  
Birth Order ◽  
Sexual Experience ◽  
Order Effect ◽  
Male Homosexuality ◽  
The Past ◽  
Older Brothers ◽  
Birth Order Effect ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order ◽  
Hormone Exposure ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order Effect

It has been established that the probability that a man is homosexual is positively related to his number of older brothers, but not older sisters when the brothers are accounted for. This is known as the ‘fraternal birth order’ effect. In the past, efforts have been made to explain this phenomenon in terms of several alternative biological hypotheses and a psychosocial hypothesis. This note examines how well these hypotheses accommodate the fraternal birth order effect. It is concluded that: (1) the evidence for the hypothesis of maternal immunoreactivity to the male fetus is weak; (2) the evidence for the intrauterine hormone exposure hypothesis is also weak; (3) the evidence for the hypothesis of postnatal learning is stronger. Lastly, there seem likely to be causes common to male homosexuality and paedophilia. They may include sexual (or quasi-sexual) experience in childhood or adolescence.

scholarly journals A method yielding comparable estimates of the fraternal birth order and female fecundity effects in male homosexuality

2020 ◽  
Vol 287 (1923) ◽  
pp. 20192907 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ray Blanchard ◽  
Jurian Krupp ◽  
Doug P. VanderLaan ◽  
Paul L. Vasey ◽  
Kenneth J. Zucker
Keyword(s):  
Birth Order ◽  
Balancing Selection ◽  
Order Effect ◽  
Effect Estimate ◽  
Male Homosexuality ◽  
Female Fecundity ◽  
Older Brothers ◽  
Birth Order Effect ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order ◽  
Fraternal Birth Order Effect

The fraternal birth order effect (FBOE) is the finding that older brothers increase the probability of homosexuality in later-born males, and the female fecundity effect (FFE) is the finding that the mothers of homosexual males produce more offspring than the mothers of heterosexual males. In a recent paper, Khovanova proposed a novel method for computing independent estimates of these effects on the same samples and expressing the magnitude and direction of the effects in the same metric. In her procedure, only families with one or two sons are examined, and daughters are ignored. The present study investigated the performance of Khovanova's method using archived data from 10 studies, comprising 14 samples totalling 5390 homosexual and heterosexual subjects. The effect estimate for the FBOE showed that an increase from zero older brothers to one older brother is associated with a 38% increase in the odds of homosexuality. By contrast, the effect estimate for the FFE showed that the increase from zero younger brothers to one younger brother is not associated with any increase in the odds of homosexuality. The former result supports the maternal immune hypothesis of male homosexuality; the latter result does not support the balancing selection hypothesis.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document