The activation peptide of mammalian trypsinogens typically contains a tetra-aspartate motif (positions P2-P5 in Schechter-Berger numbering) that inhibits autoactivation and facilitates activation by enteropeptidase. This evolutionary mechanism protects the pancreas from premature trypsinogen activation while allowing physiological activation in the gut lumen. Inborn mutations that disrupt the tetra-aspartate motif cause hereditary pancreatitis in humans. A subset of trypsinogen orthologs, including the mouse cationic trypsinogen (isoform T7), harbor an extended penta-aspartate motif (P2-P6) in their activation peptide. Here, we demonstrate that deletion of the extra P6 aspartate residue (D23del) increased autoactivation of T7 trypsinogen 3-fold. Mutagenesis of the P6 position in wild-type T7 trypsinogen revealed that bulky hydrophobic side-chains are preferred for maximal autoactivation and deletion-induced shift of the P7 Leu to P6 explains the autoactivation increase in the D23del mutant. Accordingly, removal of the P6 Leu by N-terminal truncation with chymotrypsin C reduced autoactivation of the D23del mutant. Homozygous T7D23del mice carrying the D23del mutation did not develop spontaneous pancreatitis and severity of cerulein-induced acute pancreatitis was comparable to that of C57BL/6N controls. However, sustained stimulation with cerulein resulted in markedly increased histological damage in T7D23del mice relative to C57BL/6N mice. Furthermore, when the T7D23del allele was crossed to a chymotrypsin-deficient background, the double-mutant mice developed spontaneous pancreatitis at an early age. Taken together, the observations argue that evolutionary expansion of the poly-aspartate motif in mouse cationic trypsinogen contributes to the natural defenses against pancreatitis and validate the role of the P6 position in autoactivation control of mammalian trypsinogens.