Actomyosin contractile force is harnessed for diverse functions, from cell division to morphogenesis during development. However, actomyosin contractility is intrinsically unstable to self-reinforcing spatial variations that destroy actomyosin architecture if unopposed. The full instability was rarely observed, and how cells control the instability is not established. Here, we observed the instability run its full course in isolated cytokinetic contractile rings lacking component turnover. Myosin II aggregated hierarchically into aggregates of growing size and separation up to a maximum. Molecularly explicit simulations reproduced hierarchical aggregation that precipitated tension loss and ring fracture, and identified the maximum separation as the length of actin filaments mediating mechanical communication between aggregates. Late stage simulated aggregates had aster-like morphology with polarity sorted actin, similar to late stage actomyosin systems in vitro. Our results suggest myosin II turnover controls actomyosin contractile instability in normal cells, setting myosin aggregate size and intercepting catastrophic hierarchical aggregation and fracture.