Niche specificity, polygeny, and pleiotropy in herbivorous insects
AbstractWhy do herbivorous insects tend to be host specialists? Population genetic models predict specialization when there is antagonistic pleiotropy at a gene for host-use performance. But empirically, host-use performance is governed by many genetic regions, and antagonistic pleiotropy is rare. Here, we use individual-based quantitative genetic simulations to investigate the role of pleiotropy in the evolution of host-use specialization when host-use performance is polygenic. We find that if host-preference is allowed to evolve without cost, parasite populations tend to evolve host-use specialization even without pleiotropy; thus, it would seem that for a polygenic trait, the benefit of maintaining adaptive combinations of conditionally-neutral alleles suffices to drive specialization. But if there is a fecundity cost for host-preference, or if host patches are demographically volatile, host-use generalists evolve, even with high levels of pleiotropy. In sum, if pleiotropy is much more pervasive than has been observed in nature, our simulations show that it could play a role in driving the evolution of polygenic specialization. But pleiotropy is not necessary, and even when it is extensive, selection can favor generalist genotypes.