Little is known on the natural history of ruptured isolated aneurysms of the posterior spinal artery (PSA). To date, only a few of such cases have been described in the literature. This paper aims to assess the most appropriate management strategy, based on the available literature and two new cases. In one of these, treatment was postponed until day 33, when angiography showed slight growth of the aneurysm. In the other, conservative treatment, requested by the patient, was successful. From these data, we conclude that treatment strategies for ruptured PSA aneurysms may vary. Aside from the recommendation by others to perform prompt surgical treatment, we suggest an alternative clinical paradigm allowing for the evaluation of the early clinical course. This may preclude the unnecessary treatment of spontaneously regressing lesions and still allows for appropriate treatment for persistent lesions.