Abstract. Deep convection in open ocean polynyas are common sources of error on the representation of Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW) formation in Ocean General Circulation Models. Even though those events are well described in non-assimilatory ocean simulations, recent appearance of open ocean polynya in Estimating the Circulation and Climate of the Ocean Phase II reanalysis product raises a question if this spurious event is also found in state-of-art reanalysis products. In order to answer this question, we evaluate how three recently released high-resolution ocean reanalysis form AABW in their simulations. We found that two of them (ECCO2 and SoSE) create AABW by open ocean deep convection events in Weddell Sea, showing that assimilation of sea ice has not been enough to avoid open ocean polynya appearance. The third reanalysis – My Ocean University Reading – actually creates AABW by a rather dynamically accurate mechanism, depicting both continental shelf convection, and exporting of Dense Shelf Water to open ocean. Although the accuracy of the AABW formation in this reanalysis allows an advance in represent this process, the differences found between the real ocean and the simulated one suggests that ocean reanalysis still need substantial improvements to accurately represent AABW formation.
Impact of Weddell Sea shelf progradation on Antarctic bottom water formation during the Miocene