SUMMARY
Tomographic-geodynamic model comparisons are a key component in studies of the present-day state and evolution of Earth’s mantle. To account for the limited seismic resolution, ‘tomographic filtering’ of the geodynamically predicted mantle structures is a standard processing step in this context. The filtered model provides valuable information on how heterogeneities are smeared and modified in amplitude given the available seismic data and underlying inversion strategy. An important aspect that has so far not been taken into account are the effects of data uncertainties. We present a new method for ‘tomographic filtering’ in which it is possible to include the effects of random and systematic errors in the seismic measurements and to analyse the associated uncertainties in the tomographic model space. The ‘imaged’ model is constructed by computing the generalized-inverse projection (GIP) of synthetic data calculated in an earth model of choice. An advantage of this approach is that a reparametrization onto the tomographic grid can be avoided, depending on how the synthetic data are calculated. To demonstrate the viability of the method, we compute traveltimes in an existing mantle circulation model (MCM), add specific realizations of random seismic ‘noise’ to the synthetic data and apply the generalized inverse operator of a recent Backus–Gilbert-type global S-wave tomography. GIP models based on different noise realizations show a significant variability of the shape and amplitude of seismic anomalies. This highlights the importance of interpreting tomographic images in a prudent and cautious manner. Systematic errors, such as event mislocation or imperfect crustal corrections, can be investigated by introducing an additional term to the noise component so that the resulting noise distributions are biased. In contrast to Gaussian zero-mean noise, this leads to a bias in model space; that is, the mean of all GIP realizations also is non-zero. Knowledge of the statistical properties of model uncertainties together with tomographic resolution is crucial for obtaining meaningful estimates of Earth’s present-day thermodynamic state. A practicable treatment of error propagation and uncertainty quantification will therefore be increasingly important, especially in view of geodynamic inversions that aim at ‘retrodicting’ past mantle evolution based on tomographic images.
Generalized inverse operator method in the problem of the optimal controlling of linear interconnected static plants
