scholarly journals Nonlinear analysis of the progressive collapse of reinforced concrete plane frames using a multilayered beam formulation

2014 ◽  
Vol 7 (5) ◽  
pp. 845-855
Author(s):  
C. E. M. Oliveira ◽  
E. A. P. Batelo ◽  
P. Z. Berke ◽  
R. A. M. Silveira ◽  
T. J. Massart

This work investigates the response of two reinforced concrete (RC) plane frames after the loss of a column and their potential resistance for progressive collapse. Nonlinear dynamic analysis is performed using a multilayered Euler/Bernoulli beam element, including elasto-viscoplastic effects. The material nonlinearity is represented using one-dimensional constitutive laws in the material layers, while geometrical nonlinearities are incorporated within a corotational beam formulation. The frames were designed in accordance with the minimum requirements proposed by the reinforced concrete design/building codes of Europe (fib [1-2], Eurocode 2 [3]) and Brazil (NBR 6118 [4]). The load combinations considered for PC analysis follow the prescriptions of DoD [5]. The work verifies if the minimum requirements of the considered codes are sufficient for enforcing structural safety and robustness, and also points out the major differences in terms of progressive collapse potential of the corresponding designed structures.

2018 ◽  
Vol 11 (2) ◽  
pp. 432-454
Author(s):  
D. F. A. SANTOS ◽  
A. F. LIMA NETO ◽  
M. P. FERREIRA

Abstract Punching is a possible failure mode for slender footings and it may lead a structure to ruin through progressive collapse. Although footing present different geometric characteristics, their punching shear design is based on the empirical methods used for flat slabs. This paper uses experimental results from 216 tests to evaluate the performance of design code recommendations presented by ACI 318 (2014), ABNT NBR 6118 (2014) and Eurocode 2 (2010) to estimate the punching shear resistance of reinforced concrete footings. Great dispersion between theoretical and experimental results was observed, being evident that the test system affects the punching shear capacity of footings. The more complex method proposed by Eurocode 2 resulted in a better correlation with experimental results.


2009 ◽  
Vol 36 (8) ◽  
pp. 1378-1390 ◽  
Author(s):  
Murat Saatcioglu ◽  
Togay Ozbakkaloglu ◽  
Nove Naumoski ◽  
Alan Lloyd

Recent bomb attacks on buildings have raised awareness about the vulnerability of structures to blast effects. The resiliency of structures against blast-induced impulsive loads is affected by structural characteristics that are also important for seismic resistance. Deformability and continuity of structural elements, strength, stiffness, and stability of the structural framing system and resistance to progressive collapse are factors that play important roles on the survivability of buildings under both blast and seismic loads. The significance of these structural parameters on blast resistance of reinforced concrete buildings is assessed through structural analysis. Both local element performance and global structural response are considered while also assessing the progressive collapse potential. The buildings under investigation include 10-storey moment resisting frames with or without shear walls. The blast loads selected consist of different charge-weight and standoff distance combinations. The results are presented in terms of ductility and drift demands. They indicate improved performance of seismic-resistant buildings when subjected to blast loads, in terms of local column performance, overall structural response, and progressive collapse potential.


2016 ◽  
Vol 9 (6) ◽  
pp. 883-910
Author(s):  
L.S. Tapajós ◽  
◽  
J. A .T. Ferreira ◽  
A. F. Lima Neto ◽  
M. R. Teixeira ◽  
...  

ABSTRACT This paper presents the results from a parametric study carried in order to quantify how far errors in the design stage related to the consideration of the wind action may put at risk the response and safety of reinforced concrete buildings. Using an architectural model as reference and varying the number of floors of the building, the structural safety was evaluated as a function of the wind action intensity. Results showed that even for low-rise buildings, with 10 floors, ignoring the wind action can significantly jeopardize their behaviour and safety. Yet, for slenderer buildings, up to 30 floors, it can lead to catastrophic results, as the ruin of the structure by progressive collapse.


Vestnik MGSU ◽  
2021 ◽  
pp. 1462-1472
Author(s):  
Vitaly I. Kolchunov ◽  
Pavel A. Korenkov ◽  
Dinh Quoc Phan

Introduction. The increasing number of domestic and foreign publications on structural safety and survivability of buildings and structures evidences a great interest in the study of the problem of protecting bearing systems from progressive collapse. The relevance of these studies is determined by the ongoing rise in the number of man-induced, natural and terrorist impacts on buildings and structures. In this regard, the decisive factor is the expansion of experimental and theoretical studies, focused on ensuring the required level of survivability of bearing systems under such special impacts and, respectively, developing methods for protection from progressive collapse. Materials and methods. This work presents new results of experimental studies on models of a fragment of a multi-storied building made of monolithic reinforced concrete, whose nodes, connecting the girder and the column, are reinforced with laterally reinforced meshes designed to resist operational static loads and a special emergency impact caused by the failure of one ground-floor column in the framework. Results. The article presents the results of experimental and theoretical studies on the stress-strain state and crack resistance of reinforced concrete frames or fragments of multi-storied frameworks of buildings, made of monolithic reinforced concrete. Nodes of these buildings are laterally reinforced. The data on force-induced resistance of structures were obtained for cases of the static operational loading of a structure and special emergency impacts caused by the instantaneous withdrawal of one column on the ground floor. A comparative analysis of the pace of cracking, crack development and opening is made. The co-authors have made a benchmark assessment of parameters of limit and beyond-the-limit states, as well as elements of structural systems, having nodes with/without laterally reinforced meshes. Conclusions. The co-authors have identified the nature of actual deformation and destruction of elements in the bearing system, whose nodes are laterally reinforced. The co-authors have experimentally identified the principal properties of structural elements to allow for a more rigorous assessment of deformability and the bearing capacity of the effect produced by the lateral reinforcement on the resistance of structural systems in beyond-the-limit states.


Author(s):  
Said Elkholy ◽  
Bilal El-Ariss

This paper presents a simple technique to enhance robustness of reinforced concrete (RC) plane frames to progressive collapse under column loss scenario. The response of the enhanced/mitigated RC frames is analyzed using fiber force-based finite element analysis and applying displacement-controlled nonlinear static pushdown at the location of failed column. The technique involves addition of external unbounded steel cables to the continuous beam in each floor at anchorage and deviator locations. The cables transfer the loads above the failed column to the anchorages and deviators that are assumed to perform as rigid arms, which in turn redistribute the loads to adjacent columns. The numerical model computes the frame progressive collapse robustness using push-down analysis to simulate a column elimination and estimate the effects of cable catenary action on the frame. Two-dimensional RC frame of six stories and four bays was adopted in the study. The numerical results demonstrate the prospect of increasing robustness of RC frames to progressive collapse using presented technique.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document