This chapter explores the intertwined power and impotence of human speech, starting from Eudora Welty’s story “Circe.” In “torment,” Circe seeks the secret of human grief; immortal, she finds that her words cannot reach the metaphors to which mortal speech has access. To explore this “frailty,” the chapter traces a passage from Ovid as it is cited by Shakespeare in The Tempest, Milton in Paradise Lost (at the crucial moment of Adam’s telling of his awakening into life), and then Wordsworth in the Immortality Ode. A layered confession of powerlessness is also, in each instance, an invocation of poetic power. The chapter isolates a particular phrase in Wordsworth as an index of its paradoxical formulation of the power of human frailty—“there is” of poetic positing—and then traces some of its appearances in elegiac poetry to link positing to “frailty”: in George Oppen’s “The Image of the Engine,” read as a rewriting of the Immortality Ode, and, briefly, in short poems by Mark Strand and Louise Glück. The chapter concludes by turning to the abyssal consideration of positing in a more monumental work in a different genre, albeit still in elegy: Gertrude’s speech announcing Ophelia’s death in Shakespeare’s Hamlet.