ABSTRACTClinical isolates ofPseudomonas aeruginosafrom patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) are known to differ from those associated with non-CF hosts by colony morphology, drug susceptibility patterns, and genomic hypermutability.Pseudomonas aeruginosaisolates from CF patients have long been recognized for their overall reduced rate of antimicrobial susceptibility, but their intraclonal MIC heterogeneity has long been overlooked. Using two distinct cohorts of clinical strains (n= 224 from 56 CF patients,n= 130 from 68 non-CF patients) isolated in 2013, we demonstrated profound Etest MIC heterogeneity in CFP. aeruginosaisolates in comparison to non-CFP. aeruginosaisolates. On the basis of whole-genome sequencing of 19 CFP. aeruginosaisolates from 9 patients with heterogeneous MICs, the core genome phylogenetic tree confirmed the within-patient CFP. aeruginosaclonal lineage along with considerable coding sequence variability. No extrachromosomal DNA elements or previously characterized antibiotic resistance mutations could account for the wide divergence in antimicrobial MICs betweenP. aeruginosacoisolates, though many heterogeneous mutations in efflux and porin genes and their regulators were present. A unique OprD sequence was conserved among the majority of isolates of CFP. aeruginosaanalyzed, suggesting a pseudomonal response to selective pressure that is common to the isolates. Genomic sequence data also suggested that CF pseudomonal hypermutability was not entirely due to mutations inmutL,mutS, anduvr. We conclude that the net effect of hundreds of adaptive mutations, both shared between clonally related isolate pairs and unshared, accounts for their highly heterogeneous MIC variances. We hypothesize that this heterogeneity is indicative of the pseudomonal syntrophic-like lifestyle under conditions of being “locked” inside a host focal airway environment for prolonged periods.IMPORTANCEPatients with cystic fibrosis endure “chronic focal infections” with a variety of microorganisms. One microorganism,Pseudomonas aeruginosa, adapts to the host and develops resistance to a wide range of antimicrobials. Interestingly, as the infection progresses, multiple isogenic strains ofP. aeruginosaemerge and coexist within the airways of these patients. Despite a common parental origin, the multiple strains ofP. aeruginosadevelop vastly different susceptibility patterns to actively used antimicrobial agents—a phenomenon we define as “heterogeneous MICs.” By sequencing pairs ofP. aeruginosaisolates displaying heterogeneous MICs, we observed widespread isogenic gene lesions in drug transporters, DNA mismatch repair machinery, and many other structural or cellular functions. Coupled with the heterogeneous MICs, these genetic lesions demonstrated a symbiotic response to host selection and suggested evolution of a multicellular syntrophic bacterial lifestyle. Current laboratory standard interpretive criteria do not address the emergence of heterogeneous growth and susceptibilitiesin vitrowith treatment implications.
Heterogeneous Antimicrobial Susceptibility Characteristics inPseudomonas aeruginosaIsolates from Cystic Fibrosis Patients
