Giving Useful but Not Well-Understood Ideas Their Due

Author(s):  
Adam Omelianchuk

AbstractIn this paper, I introduce the ideas to be discussed in the articles of this journal with reference to an imaginary case involving a pregnant woman declared dead on the basis of neurological criteria. I highlight the fact that although these ideas have proved useful for advancing certain claims in bioethical debates, their implications are not always well understood and may complicate our arguments. The ideas to be discussed are (1) an ethic internal to the profession of medicine; (2) the difference between killing and letting die; (3) the organism as a whole; and (4) the “lives” and interests of the dead.

Dialogue ◽  
1981 ◽  
Vol 20 (1) ◽  
pp. 68-78
Author(s):  
Douglas N. Walton

Routinely, in Arriving at decisions on what treatments to recommend in intensive care wards, the moral presumption is that there is an intrinsic difference between the positive duty to save lives and the negative duty not to take lives. The discontinuation of treatment – say stopping chemotherapy or removing a ventilator – is thought of as a “negative” action, an allowing to die, not “positively”, say as an act of suicide by the patient, or a killing by the hospital staff. But the distinction between “positive” and “negative” here, despite its grave ethical import, is elusive and difficult to grasp firmly. St. Anselm of Canterbury was fond of citing the trickiness of the distinction between “to do” (facere) and “not to do” (non-facere). In answer to the question “What's he doing?” we say “He's just sitting there.” (positive), really meaning something negative: “He's not doing anything at all.” Sometimes the “negative” action is described in “positive” terms, or vice versa, and that makes one wonder if the distinction might be somehow trivial, a bit of jesuitry too insubstantial to bear much serious ethical weight.


Author(s):  
Ariel Toaff

This chapter examines Jewish cemeteries, wills, and funerals. One of the first religious requirements of each Jewish community in Umbria, whatever its size, was its own cemetery; the cemetery boundary expanded and contracted in line with the community's growth or decline. While Christians chose their last resting-place in the churches or in their adjacent cemeteries, Jews were allotted peripheral burial-places, well out of town. This physical separation of the dead in some sense highlighted the difference in status between ‘established’ Christian citizens and Jews, who were merely tolerated and granted temporary citizenship. Meanwhile, for Italian Jews, a will was not only a private legal deed settling the inheritance of property; it was also a religious act through which the believer expressed their desire to be buried in the Jewish cemetery, acknowledged their sins, and redeemed them through appropriate bequests. The chapter then studies Jewish funerals. Jewish funeral processions sometimes aroused people's most aggressive instincts, and on such occasions, the Jews became the target not only of insults, obscenities, and boorish comments, but of vicious and even fatal stonings.


2011 ◽  
pp. 88-93
Author(s):  
James R. Munis

Physiologically, what is the difference between a patient undergoing deep hypothermic circulatory arrest and another patient who has died and cooled to the same temperature? The answer resides inside the cells. During hypothermic arrest, physiologic functions of whole-organ systems are temporarily arrested, but the cells are still busy. Cellular metabolism is also slowed, but it's not completely stopped. One difference between the hypothermic-arrest patient and the dead patient is that the former has live cells and the latter has dead cells. And furthermore, one of the differences between live cells and dead cells is that live cells maintain certain important gradients across their membranes. Another difference is that dead cells have no metabolism. We often refer to cellular metabolism as ‘respiration,’ and we measure it by calculating how much oxygen is being used. This brings us to oxygen. Why do we define cellular metabolism in terms of oxygen consumption?


Radiocarbon ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 62 (5) ◽  
pp. 1453-1473
Author(s):  
Nurit Weber ◽  
Boaz Lazar ◽  
Ofra Stern ◽  
George Burr ◽  
Ittai Gavrieli ◽  
...  

ABSTRACTThe sources and fate of radiocarbon (14C) in the Dead Sea hypersaline solution are evaluated with 14C measurements in organic debris and primary aragonite collected from exposures of the Holocene Ze’elim Formation. The reservoir age (RA) is defined as the difference between the radiocarbon age of the aragonite at time of its precipitation (representing lakeʼs dissolved inorganic carbon [DIC]) and the age of contemporaneous organic debris (representing atmospheric radiocarbon). Evaluation of the data for the past 6000 yr from Dead Sea sediments reveal that the lakeʼs RA decreased from 2890 yr at 6 cal kyr BP to 2300 yr at present. The RA lies at ~2400 yr during the past 3000 yr, when the lake was characterized by continuous deposition of primary aragonite, which implies a continuous supply of freshwater-bicarbonate into the lake. This process reflects the overall stability of the hydrological-climate conditions in the lakeʼs watershed during the late Holocene where bicarbonate originated from dissolution of the surface cover in the watershed that was transported to the Dead Sea by the freshwater runoff. An excellent correlation (R2=0.98) exists between aragonite ages and contemporaneous organic debris, allowing the estimation of ages of various primary deposits where organic debris are not available.


2012 ◽  
Author(s):  
Wan Ramli Wan Daud

Although ultrafiltration and hyperfiltration have replaced many liquid phase separation equipment, both are still considered as “non–unit operation” processes because the sizing of both equipments could not be calculated using either the equilibrium stage, or the rate–based methods. Previous design methods using the dead–end and complete–mixing models are unsatisfactory because the dead–end model tends to underestimate the membrane area, due to the use of the feed concentration in the driving force, while the complete–mixing model tends to overestimate the membrane area, due to the use of a more concentrated rejection concentration in the driving force. In this paper, cross–flow models for both ultrafiltration and hyperfiltration are developed by considering mass balance at a differential element of the cross–flow module, and then integrating the expression over the whole module to get the module length. Since the modeling is rated–based, the length of both modules could be expressed as the product of the height of a transfer unit (HTU), and the number of transfer unit (NTU). The solution of the integral representing the NTU of ultrafiltration is found to be the difference between two exponential integrals (Ei(x)) while that representing the NTU of hyperfiltration is found to be the difference between two hypergeometric functions. The poles of both solutions represent the flux extinction curves of ultrafiltration and hyperfiltration. The NTU for ultrafiltration is found to depend on three parameters: the rejection R, the recovery S, and the dimensionless gel concentration Cg. For any given Cg and R, the recovery, S, is limited by the corresponding flux extinction curve. The NTU for hyperfiltration is found to depend on four parameters: the rejection R, the recovery S, the polarization β, and the dimensionless applied pressure difference ψ. For any given ψ and R, the recovery, S, is limited by the corresponding flux extinction curve. The NTU for both ultrafiltration and hyperfiltration is found to be generally small and less than unity but increases rapidly to infinity near the poles due to flux extinction. Polarization is found to increase the NTU and hence the length and membrane area of the hollow fiber module for hyperfiltration. Key words: Ultrafiltration; hyperfiltration; reverse osmosis; hollow fiber module design; crossflow model; number of transfer unit; height of a transfer unit


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document