On: “RECENT TECHNIQUES FOR DETERMINATION OF IN SITU ELASTIC PROPERTIES AND MEASUREMENT OF MOTION AMPLIFICATION IN LAYERED MEDIA,” BY R.J. SWAIN (GEOPHYSICS, APRIL, 1962, PP. 237–241).
Although I am in general agreement with Mr. Swain’s paper, there are several pitfalls inherent in the use of dynamic elastic constants which should not be ignored. The strength of materials and the elastic properties both undoubtedly depend on the rate of loading and/or the stress levels involved. It does not seem appropriate, therefore, to use dynamic in situ elastic properties for static design problems. The specific design problem at hand should determine the relative value placed on the use of static or dynamic elastic constants. The dynamic in situ values are generally more reliable than those obtained in the laboratory as indicated by Mr. Swain, although continued development of the laboratory pulse and critical‐angle method shows promise of improving the reliability of laboratory values.