Settling Accounts: The Intergenerational Contract in an Age of Reform

Author(s):  
Deborah Davis ◽  
Stevan Harrell
2021 ◽  
Vol 42 (1) ◽  
pp. 97-111
Author(s):  
Paro Mishra ◽  
Ravinder Kaur

This paper maps the impact of gender imbalance on intergenerational relations in north India. It uses the idea of multiple biological clocks to understand the impact that gender imbalance and male marriage squeeze have on two categories of persons: “overage” unmarried sons and their aging parents, and the inter-generational contract between them within the family-household. De-linking the idea of the biological clock from the female body, this paper demonstrates that social understandings of bodily progression are equally significant for men, who, in the Indian context, need to marry by a certain age, and their elderly parents who need to be cared for. In north India, where family-household unit is the most important welfare and security institution for the elderly, disruptions to household formation due to bride shortage caused by sex ratio imbalance, is subjecting families to severe stress. Families with unmarried sons struggle with anxieties centred on the inability to arrange marriages for aging sons, questions of allocation of household labor, the continuation of family line, and lack of care for the elderly. Based on ethnographic fieldwork in north India, this paper explores the tensions and negotiations between elderly parents and unmarried sons concerning the fulfillment (or lack of it) of the intergenerational contract against the backdrop of gender imbalance. It concludes by discussing the various strategies available to families in crisis that involve shame-faced adoption of domestic and care tasks by unmarried sons or bringing cross-region brides who then provide productive, reproductive, and care labour.


Author(s):  
Elizabeth Finneron-Burns

Because they are funded on a pay-as-you-go basis, universal state pension schemes are long-term intergenerational contracts. In them, one working generation (G2) contracts with retirees (G1) to fund their retirement. Unlike in a standard contract, G1 does not offer anything to G2. Rather, G3 (G2’s children and grandchildren) will be expected to fund G2’s retirement in turn. In this way, G1 and G2 have bound G3 into a contract without their tacit or express consent (because they do not exist to give it at the time of the contract). In this chapter the author interrogates the foundational question of whether an intergenerational contract of this nature is just. The author anticipates that a model of hypothetical consent will help make sense of the binding nature of such a contract. However, the author also argues that if hypothetical consent is relied upon to justify such contracts, it will place unexpected obligations on G2, including the obligation to reproduce or support high levels of immigration, and rights for G3, including the right to heavily tax G2 if they do not discharge the aforementioned duties.


2015 ◽  
Vol 224 ◽  
pp. 1026-1047 ◽  
Author(s):  
Lisa Eklund

AbstractDrawing from ethnographic data from 48 households in four villages in rural Anhui, this study explores how two practices known for upholding son preference are affected by rural–urban out-migration, with a particular focus on the division of labour in agricultural work and patrilocality. The study deploys the concepts of an intergenerational contract and the “unsubstitutability” of sons and finds that a weakening of the intergenerational contract can take place without substantially challenging the unsubstitutability of sons. The study concludes that although male out-migration undermines the argument that sons are needed to secure male manual labour in family farming, the vital role of male labour as a rural livelihood strategy largely persists. Moreover, although the study identifies migration-induced exceptions, patrilocality remains the main organizing principle for social and economic life for both male and female migrants. Hence, the study finds little support for the prospect that migration is attenuating son preference in rural China.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document