Quality of Life in a Randomized Trial Comparing Two Neoadjuvant Regimens for Locally Advanced Rectal Cancer – INCAGI004.
Abstract Background: Neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy (neoCRT) followed by surgery is the standard of care for locally advanced rectal cancer (LARC), but the emergence of different drug regimens may result in different response rates. Good clinical response translates into greater sphincter preservation, but quality of life (QOL) may be impaired after treatment due to chemoradiotherapy and surgical side effects. Objective: To prospectively evaluate the QOL in a randomized trial comparing two neoadjuvant regimens for locally advanced rectal cancer.Methods: Stage II and III rectal cancer patients were randomized to receive neoCRT with either capecitabine (Group 1) or 5-Fu and leucovorin (Group 2) concomitant to long course radiotherapy. Clinical downstaging was accessed using MRI 6-8 weeks after treatment. EORTCs QLQ C30 and CR38 were applied before treatment (T0), after neoCRT (T1), after rectal resection (T2), early after adjuvant chemotherapy (T3), and one year after end of treatment or stoma closure (T4). Wexner scale was used for continence evaluation at T4. A C30SummaryScore (Geisinger et cols) was calculated to compare QOL results. Results: 32 patients were assigned to Group 1 and 31 to Group 2. Clinical downstaging occurred in 70.0% of Group 1 and 53.3% of Group 2 (p=0.288). pCR was 23.3% in group 1 and 10.0% in Group 2(p=0.165). Sphincter preservation was 83.3% in Group 1 and 80.0% in Group 2(p=0.111). No difference in QOL was detected comparing the two treatment groups before and after neoCRT. C30SummaryScore detected improvement comparing T0 to T1 and deterioration comparing T1 to T2 (p=0.025), and global health status improved at T1 and T4 compared to T0(p=0.004). Mean Wexner scale score was 9.2, and a high score correlated with symptoms of diarrhea and defecation problems at T4.Conclusions: Clinical and pathological response rates were equivalent in both treatment groups. QOL was improved after neoCRT corresponding to clinical response but decreased following rectal resection. Wexner score was high after sphincter preservation. C30SummaryScore was a useful tool to detect differences in overall QOL in EORTCs multiple item questionnaire.Trial registration: NCT03428529. Registered 02/09/2018 - Retrospectively registered, https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03428529.