Use of Mannitol and Saline Solution in the management of ICP in patients with Traumatic Brain Injury: Evidence of superiority?
Background: Mannitol (MT) and Hypertonic Saline Solution (HSS) exert an osmotic effect by lowering Intracranial Pressure (ICP) in patients with Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), but there are doubts as to which is more efficient. Objective: Analyze the use of MT and HSS in the management of ICP in patients suffering from TBI. Design and Settings: This is a literature review, produced by medical students from Bahia, Brazil. Methods: The evaluated studies were obtained in PubMed, with MeSH terms, published since 1988. The studies that did not correspond with the purpose of this review were excluded. Results: 34 of the 114 articles found, were selected. Observational and laboratory studies have shown an advantage in the use of SSH to reduce ICP and a longer duration of the effect in relation to MT. However, clinical trials and meta-analyzes do not show significant differences in relation to MT and SSH for reducing ICP, however they describe a slight preference for the use of SSH. As for side effects, MT mainly causes hemodynamic changes such as hypotension and SSH causes a significant increase in serum sodium concentration. Conclusion: Although there are benefits to both the use of TM and SSH, there is a preference to use SSH for the management of ICP in patients with TBI. The studies were not enough to show superiority in relation to these solutions and new Clinical Trials must be carried out.