scholarly journals Protection of the rights of the weaker contracting party in accordance with the Principles of European Insurance Contract Law

2020 ◽  
pp. 57-73
Author(s):  
Mirjana Glintić

An analysis of not only domestic but also comparative legislation indicates the continued presence of the former trend in regulation of insurance contract law, which reflects the legislator's tendencies to protect the insurer from the policyholder's fraudulent conduct. However, certain legal systems have begun to amend their regulations in order to keep up with contemporary tendencies, reflected in providing the necessary protection to the weaker party, i.e. consumer. Therefore, the author analyses the mechanisms of protection of this contracting party presented in the Principles of European Contract Law on Insurance, because it is a source of soft law, whose authors sought to sublimate as many well balanced provisions as possible in order to achieve a higher level of protection for the weaker contracting party. The Paper analyses only some of the provisions of the Principles that strive to ensure the expansion in the scope of the policyholders' rights, while reducing their duties, on one hand, and excluding too severe sanctions in case of their misconduct, on the other hand. Even though it is high unlikely that any steps will be taken towards PEICL enactment by EU regulations, at least in the near future, there remains possibility for their impact at the legislative and scientific level. This is also testified by this paper, which can contribute to the review of current domestic legal solutions.

2017 ◽  
Vol 4 (2) ◽  
pp. 41
Author(s):  
Zdzisław Brodecki ◽  
Katarzyna Malinowska

Tendencies on Internal Insurance Market vis a vis Harmonization of European Insurance Contract LawSummaryIn the paper, the authors describe the main contemporary process which takes place w ithin the insurance contract law in Europe - viz the Euro-merge of private law, as well as the evolution of the insurance contract law during the last decades. The process o f the unification of European private law will also affect the insurance contract law. First of all the impact o f the development o f the ideas shaped in a form of general contract law drafted as the Restatement of the Principles of European Contract Law by the „Lando Group” is undeniable. These rules also applicable to some extent to insurance contracts show that the process of the unification o f insurance contract law cannot be stopped and that it will constantly develop. There can also be observed a process of a specific European com m on law being developed in Europe in different branches, such as product liability, consumer protection, etc. This already influences the harmonization o f the European insurance contract law, and the obstacles to harmonization, existing even ten years ago, have disappeared. The Restatement o f Insurance Contract Law being in preparation by the „Group of Innsbruck” will probably constitute a basis for a future codification o f the insurance contract law.


Author(s):  
E. Allan Farnsworth

This article presents an overview of comparative contract law. It reveals a number of differences between civilian legal systems and the common law, and also between French and German law as two main exponents of the civil-law tradition and, to some extent, even between English and US-American law. The same is true of other major issues in the field of general contract law that have not been touched upon. But there is a gradual convergence. This convergence is due to developments in all of the four legal systems covered in this article: English, US-American, French, and German law. And it has enabled scholars from around the world to elaborate an international restatement of contract law (the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts) and scholars from all the member states of the European Union to formulate a restatement of European contract law (the Principles of European Contract Law).


Author(s):  
Huber Peter

Section 7.3 of the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts (PICC) deals with the aggrieved party's right to terminate the contract if the other party does not perform. However, the PICC also severely restrict the scope of termination as a remedy. The crucial question is not whether there is a right to terminate, but rather when it will be available to the aggrieved party. Art 7.3.1(1) accepts the doctrine of fundamental breach as the basic rule for the availability of termination. For cases of delay, Art 7.3.1(3) introduces the Nachfrist mechanism. The basic structure of the system of remedies in Section 7.3 bears a strong resemblance to both the Commission on European Contract Law, Principles of European Contract Law (1998), and the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) regimes.


2017 ◽  
pp. 93-122
Author(s):  
Magdalena Dziedzic

In European contract law and consumer law the nature of protection through information is based on imposing on business an obligation to make a declaration of knowledge to a consumer, which should enable them to make a rational decision. The implementation of efficient regulations regarding the liability for the improper fulfillment of information duties aims to maintain the level of trust between contracting parties on optimal level, and, as a result, to lead to balancing of their position respecting the freedom of contract principle. Polish model of consumer protection through information, in particular in the area of the liability for the improper fulfillment of information duties by business requires a lot of changes. In national law it is specially problematic, the lack of definition of general, legal consequences of failure to provide obligatory information, providing it in an incomplete, unclear way, but without the intention to mislead the other party.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document