Investigation of Deformation-Based Damage Limits of RC Columns for Different Seismic Codes

The seismic performance of reinforced-concrete columns is related to the expected damage limits under seismic loads and how this damage relates to safety of the structure. In order to assess the performance of reinforced-concrete columns under seismic loads, performance-based deformation and damage limits are proposed by the seismic codes. Adequacy of the deformation and damage limit levels given in the codes such as Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of Existing Buildings Standard, ASCE/SEI-41 (2017) and Turkish Building Earthquake Code (2018) were evaluated by carrying out parametric studies for RC columns. Reinforced-concrete circular columns are designed in parametric studies to present the effects of various parameters such as concrete compressive strength, axial load levels and spiral reinforcement ratio on performance-based damage limits. Performance limits corresponding to each performance levels obtained by different seismic guidelines were compared. When the results obtained from the analyzes are examined, it has been observed that there are significantly different results in the cross-section damage limits values of ASCE/SEI-41 (2017) and TBEC (2018) regulation, which can change the performance level of the building. TBEC (2018) gives approximately 50% conservative limitations when they are compared with the ASCE/SEI-41 (2017) limitations. As a result, TBDY (2018) seems to offer safer and ductile solutions than ASCE ASCE/SEI-41 (2017).