Based on the biological, nutrients and hydrological data in August 2018, the vertical chlorophyll a (Chl-a) concentration profiles and the relationship among surface Chl-a (Chl-a(0)) concentration, maximum Chl-a (Chl-a(m)) concentration and depth-integrated Chl-a (Chl-a(int)) concentration were studied in the Northern South China Sea (NSCS). The results indicate that there are 4 different patterns in the vertical Chl-a profiles in the NSCS: (i) Chl-a increases with depth from the surface (e.g. station 1); (ii) there exists subsurface chlorophyll maximum (SCM), with low Chl-a on the surface and at the bottom layers respectively (e.g. station 5); (iii) there is no SCM, only with high Chl-a on the surface and in the bottom (e.g. station 14); (iv) the 4th pattern is similar to (ii), with the higher Chl-a(0) (e.g. station 28). The SCM is observed at 95% stations in the NSCS and is not detected only at a few stations near the Pearl River (PR) estuary. These patterns are mainly regulated by alternative limitation of nutrients and light from the surface to the bottom of euphotic layer. For the pattern 1 (e.g. station 1), light is not a limited factor, and Chl-a and nutrients increase with depth. The pattern 2 (e.g. station 5) exists with the limitation of surface nutrients in offshore region. The nutrients increases with depth and the nutrients limitation turns to light limitation gradually from surface to bottom. And the SCM appears in the layer which need of the light and nutrients is roughly equivalent. Compared with that the offshore SCM, the nutrients for the pattern 3 (e.g. station 14) are rich on the surface with nutrients concentration and light irradiance. Therefore, it is seawater intrusion from the bottom that brings the higher nutrients concentration. The reason for the high Chl-a(0) on the pattern 4 (e.g. station 28) is terrestrial matter from the nearshore. High correlation (R2 = 0.5206, p<0.01) between the depth of SCM (Depth(m)) and Chl-a(0) indicates that the SCM depth is regulated by light masking effect of surface phytoplankton, generally with shallow nutriclines and fast light attenuation for high Chl-a(0) and vice versa low Chl-a(0) brings deeper nutriclines and light attenuate slowly with less shading effect. Further research results shows that Chl-a(int) and Chl-a(m) have a good correlation(R2 = 0.6397, p<0.01). However, the correlation between Chl-a(int) and Chl-a(0) is relative weak (R2 = 0.3202, p<0.01). That could be attributed to the availability of nutrients playing an important role in growth of phytoplankton, with high nutrients at upper euphotic layers for the stations with high Chl-a(0).
Referee comments on The Influence of Turbulent Mixing on the Subsurface Chlorophyll Maximum Layer in the Northern South China Sea by authors: Chenjing Shang et al. MS No.: os-2020-26
