Some optimum age structures and selection methods in open nucleus breeding schemes with overlapping generations

ABSTRACTDesigns of open nucleus breeding schemes, which comprise a nucleus having the best males and females and a base comprising the remainder, with some base-born individuals used in the nucleus and vice versa, are studied.Steady-state genetic responses, optimum transfer rates between nucleus and base in both sexes, and genetic differences between nucleus and base are estimated for a range of age structures, selection either within or among age groups (selection methods), nucleus sizes, mating ratios, fertility rates and survival rates appropriate to sheep and cattle populations. With optimum transfer rates between layers maximum or near maximum genetic responses are obtained with nucleus sizes varying from 2 to 15% of the population. Optimum transfer rates are fairly stable for nucleus sizes larger than about 5% and where the same selection procedures are used in both layers. However, a small nucleus with more efficient age structures and selection procedures and more accurate selection than in the base is economically desirable, and then almost no base-born females should be selected as nucleus replacements and up to 70% of male replacements for the base should come from the base. Optimum age structures differed markedly between selection methods.Although few ‘rules of thumb’ about optimum age structures and transfer rates are sufficiently robust to be widely recommended in commercial situations, the nucleus breeding system behaves according to a few basic principles that can be used to predict the direction if not the magnitude of effects of changes in structure.