Certain Activities Carried Out by Nicaragua in the Border Area

International Court of Justice — Provisional measures — Requirements for the indication of provisional measures — Prima facie jurisdiction — Jurisdiction under American Treaty on Pacific Settlement, 1948 (Pact of Bogotá) — Plausibility of rights claimed — Whether rights claimed by Costa Rica plausible — Irreparable damage — Whether rights claimed by Costa Rica at imminent risk of irreparable prejudiceInternational Court of Justice — Procedure — Control of proceedings — Joinder of proceedings — Counter-claims — Admissibility of counter-claims — Whether counter-claims of Nicaragua having direct connection with main claim of Costa Rica — Conditions for establishing whether a counter-claim connected in fact and in law with main claimInternational Court of Justice — Evidence — Weight to be given — Expert evidence — Burden and standard of proof — CompensationTerritory — Sovereignty — Disputed territory — Costa Rica’s claim that Nicaragua carried out activities in territory under sovereignty of Costa Rica — Extent of disputed territory — Treaty of Limits, 1858 — Cleveland Award, 1888 — Alexander Awards, 1897 — Whether “first channel met” was the caño dredged by Nicaragua starting in 2010 — Whether disputed territory falling under sovereignty of NicaraguaEnvironment — Procedural obligations — Substantive obligations — Nicaragua’s alleged breaches of international environmental law — Whether Nicaragua having to provide Costa Rica with environmental impact assessment relating to activities in disputed territory — Whether Nicaragua breaching its obligations to notify and consult with Costa Rica — Whether Nicaragua breaching its obligation not to cause transboundary harm — Costa Rica’s alleged breaches of international environmental law — Whether Costa Rica breaching its obligation to provide Nicaragua with environmental impact assessment relating to construction of Road 1856 along San Juan River — Whether Costa Rica breaching its obligations to notify and consult with Nicaragua — Whether Costa Rica breaching its obligations under Convention on Biological Diversity, 1992 — Whether Costa Rica breaching its obligation not to cause 2transboundary harm — Whether Costa Rica breaching Nicaragua’s territorial integrityRivers — Right of navigation — Whether Nicaragua breaching Costa Rica’s right of navigation on San Juan River under Treaty of Limits, 1858 — PollutionState responsibility — Breach of provisional measures — Whether evidence showing that Nicaragua breached provisional measures — Assessing compliance with provisional measures at merits stage — Costs — Whether Costa Rica to be awarded costs as a result of Nicaragua’s breach of provisional measures — Breach of territorial integrity — Presence of Nicaragua’s military camp in disputed territory — Declaration that territorial integrity had been breached — Reparation — Compensation to be determined by Parties through negotiation within a year — Whether Court to be requested to determine amount of compensation by either Party after one year had elapsedDamages — Environmental damage — Consequences of responsibility for environmental damage — Request by Costa Rica to determine amount of compensation — Obligation to make full reparation — Hierarchy of means of reparation — Punitive or exemplary damages — Three-step approach to awarding compensation — Establishment of unlawful act — Causal link between unlawful act and injury suffered — Quantification — Compensation for environmental damage — Compensation for expenses incurred by Costa Rica — Methodology to quantify amount due — Parties disagreeing on appropriate methodology — Expenses by Costa Rica as a result of unlawful activities in disputed territory — Expenses by Costa Rica as a result of Nicaragua’s breach of provisional measures — Expenses by Costa Rica for construction and monitoring of a dyke — Costa Rica’s claim for pre-judgment and post-judgment interest — Whether pre-judgment interest necessary to ensure full reparation — Date by which compensation to be paid by Nicaragua