Many plants and animals adaptively downsize the number of already-produced propagules if resources become insufficient to raise all of them. In birds, mothers often induce hatching asynchrony by incubating first eggs before last eggs are laid, creating an age/size hierarchy within broods which selectively eliminates the smallest chicks in poor food conditions. However, mothers also deposit more testosterone into late-laid eggs, which boosts competitive abilities of younger chicks, counteracts the competitive hierarchy, and ostensibly creates a paradox. Since testosterone also carries costs, we hypothesized that benefits of maternally deposited testosterone outweigh its costs in good food conditions, but that testosterone has a net detrimental effect in poor food conditions. We found experimental evidence that elevated maternal testosterone in the egg caused higher chick mortality in poor food conditions but better chick growth in good food conditions. These context-dependent effects resolve the paradox, suggesting co-evolution of two maternal effects, and explain inconsistent results of egg hormone manipulations in the literature.
Migratory constraints on yolk precursors limit yolk androgen deposition and underlie a brood reduction strategy in rockhopper penguins
