Now You SCC Me, Now You Don’t: Using Machine Learning to Find Stress Corrosion Cracking

Author(s):  
Michael Smith ◽  
Aidan Blenkinsop ◽  
Matthew Capewell ◽  
Brian Kerrigan

Abstract Electromagnetic Acoustic Transducer (EMAT) is a non-destructive inspection technology that uses guided acoustic waves to detect planar flaws in a metal structure. When deployed via in-line inspection (ILI), it is an effective way to detect cracks in a pipeline. EMAT has thus become a staple of crack management programs throughout the world since its introduction to the market over a decade ago. As with all technologies, challenges remain with the inspection process. One such challenge with EMAT is classification. While it is possible to determine that a defect is “crack-like” (a property determined by its tendency to reflect incident waves), it is difficult to determine the nature of the defect from the EMAT measurement alone. Indeed, similar reflections are obtained for many different types of defects, from relatively benign manufacturing and construction abnormalities, to more concerning anomalies such as stress corrosion cracking (SCC). To compensate for the difficulties in classification, it is good practice to follow up an EMAT inspection with a number of in-field verifications. These investigations allow for a more direct observation of classification and size, and provide valuable information about the nature of cracks. They are, however, expensive — meaning that avoiding unnecessary digs is a top priority. In this paper, we document a developing approach to post-ILI crack management, whereby the results of an EMAT run are combined with those from field verifications to maximize the amount of information gained from costly field work. This approach — which relies on supervised machine learning — leads to a marked improvement in the classification of crack-like indications from EMAT, and allows future investigations to be prioritized according to the likelihood of finding a concerning defect. The method was trialed on a pipeline system with extensive SCC, leading to an improved success rate in finding SCC, and a more cost effective crack management plan.

Author(s):  
Neil Bates ◽  
Mark Brimacombe ◽  
Steven Polasik

A pipeline operator set out to assess the risk of circumferential stress corrosion cracking and to develop a proactive management program, which included an in-line inspection and repair program. The first step was to screen the total pipeline inventory based on pipe properties and environmental factors to develop a susceptibility assessment. When a pipeline was found to be susceptible, an inspection plan was developed which often included ultrasonic circumferential crack detection in-line inspection and geotechnical analysis of slopes. Next, a methodology was developed to prioritize the anomalies for investigation based on the likelihood of failure using the provided in-line inspection sizing data, crack severity analysis, and correlation to potential causes of axial or bending stress, combined with a consequence assessment. Excavation programs were then developed to target the anomalies that posed the greatest threat to the pipeline system or environment. This paper summarizes the experiences to date from the operator’s circumferential stress corrosion cracking program and describes how the pipeline properties, geotechnical program, and/or in-line inspection programs were combined to determine the susceptibility of each pipeline and develop excavation programs. In-line inspection reported crack types and sizes compared to field inspection data will be summarized, as well as how the population and severity of circumferential stress corrosion cracking found compares to the susceptible slopes found in the geotechnical program completed. Finally, how the circumferential SCC time-average growth rate distributions were calculated and were used to set future geohazard inspections, in-line inspections, or repair dates will be discussed.


Author(s):  
Brett Johnson ◽  
Bereket Tesfaye ◽  
Cory Wargacki ◽  
Thomas Hennig ◽  
Ernesto Suarez

Since the late 1980’s Ultrasonic tools have been used for the detection and sizing of crack like indications. ILI service providers developed inspection technologies for liquid and gas lines that are widely used nowadays. In comparison to axial cracking, circumferential cracking is not a prevalent risk to most pipelines and therefore is not as well understood. Nevertheless, pipeline Operators observe from time to time circumferentially oriented defects, often in combination with circumferential welds or local stress/strain accumulations. These are often caused by pipeline movement, which may especially occur in mountain areas. With the introduction of Ultrasonic circumferential crack inspection tools in the late 2000’s the knowledge has steadily increased over time. Extensive data collected from in-ditch NDE validations has provided NDT Global with an increased knowledge of the morphology of single cracking and stress corrosion cracking defects both in the axial and circumferential orientations. Field verifications have shown that not all features have the same morphology. Some of the challenges with circumferential cracking are for features that fall outside of the industry standard specifications. These types of features can exhibit characteristics such as being sloped, skewed or tilted. In 2016 NDT Global was approached by Plains Midstream Canada to complete inspections utilizing the 10″ Ultrasonic Circumferential crack inspection technology. The pipeline system spans 188km within Canada and consists of 2 segments. The pipeline traverses several elevation changes and crosses several creeks and roads. Circumferential cracking was identified during dig campaigns performed for other threats, therefore the need to inspect each pipeline segment with the Ultrasonic circumferential technology was identified. Plains Midstream Canada and NDT Global formed a close collaboration to assess the severity of circumferential crack features in this line. This paper will discuss integrity aspects from an Operator and Vendor perspective. Challenges identified due to the morphology of the circumferential crack like indications and derived analysis rules and interpretation methodologies to optimize characterization and sizing are presented. Finally, potential opportunities to maintain the integrity of similar assets by applying some of the findings and enhance the management and decision making process are suggested.


Author(s):  
Dennis C. Johnston ◽  
Thomas G. Hrncir

Marathon Ashland Pipe Line LLC (MAPL) experienced a pipeline release on January 27, 2000 from cracking in a bottom-side shallow deformation. The crack that caused the release was determined to have propagated due to corrosion fatigue that progressed from an area of near-neutral pH stress corrosion cracks. A combination of a transverse field magnetic flux inspection (TFI) tool and a slope-deformation tool were used to inspect the entire pipeline segment for additional injurious deformations that could contain cracks. The TFI tool data were used to differentiate deformations that contained linear indications (typically cracks or corrosion) from deformations that did not. The slope-deformation tool data were used to measure the deformation magnitudes and shapes and to assist with locating the (TFI) deformations that were to be excavated. The pipe conditions necessary for these types of cracking to occur are discussed as well as the findings of the in-line inspection and remediation program. Prior to this release, it was perceived within the industry that constrained shallow deformations were not likely to fail catastrophically. The failure mechanism, particularly from constrained deformations, was normally as a leak. The near-neutral pH stress corrosion cracking phenomenon within deformations was first thought to be a unique event. Based on the investigation program conducted by MAPL, this phenomenon was identified elsewhere within the pipeline system. Based on MAPL’s investigation, pipelines susceptible to or containing slight deformations (typically high D/t ratios) in areas with groundwater containing high levels of dissolved carbon dioxide and coated with materials prone to shielding cathodic protection may be particularly susceptible to the deformation near-neutral pH stress corrosion cracking phenomenon.


Author(s):  
Amal Elsisi ◽  
Winston Y. W. Lee ◽  
Pushpendra Tomar ◽  
Dan Williams

Abstract Gas transmission pipeline operators increasingly rely on Electro-Magnetic Acoustic Transducer (EMAT) technology to reliably detect, identify and size stress corrosion cracking (SCC) anomalies in their pipeline system. However, scheduling EMAT in-line inspection (ILI) on every pipeline in the system is not always practicable or achievable in an expeditious manner. A means of conducting a preliminary assessment of the SCC threat on pipelines without EMAT ILI data in an objective and quantifiable manner is useful for understanding the threat level and for prioritizing or deciding on outstanding EMAT inspections. A wealth of system-specific SCC field data from historical integrity excavations across the pipeline system typically exists in a pipeline operator’s dataset and can be readily leveraged for quantitatively estimating the SCC threat reliability in other, similar (“like-in-kind”) parts of the pipeline system. This system-specific data, based on actual SCC findings from integrity excavations, is an improved and more granular alternative to applying industry-wide SCC statistics to estimates of SCC reliability levels on pipelines without EMAT ILI data. This paper presents a robust and direct limit state approach for estimating the SCC reliability level in pipelines that have not yet had an EMAT ILI completed by leveraging system-wide SCC field findings from historical integrity excavations.


Author(s):  
Jim Marr ◽  
Stephan Tappert ◽  
Elvis San Juan Riverol ◽  
Andy Mann ◽  
Jo¨rg Weislogel ◽  
...  

TransCanada typically manages the integrity of sections of gas transmission pipelines that are susceptible to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) by periodically performing hydrostatic testing. Interest in an alternative approach to manage pipeline integrity in the presence of SCC and other forms of longitudinally oriented defects resulted in the endorsement of the latest generation of dry coupled in-line inspection tool. GE’s EMAT In-Line Inspection (ILI) tool uses the electromagnetic acoustic transducer technology to meet this requirement. This paper will summarize field experience results of the latest generation Emat In-Line inspection tool, which is commercial available since September 2008. It demonstrates, that the challenges have been overcome, the targets have been achieved, and the tool delivers the information of a distinguished ability of detection, sizing and discrimination performance, key parameters to conduct an effective pipeline integrity program.


Author(s):  
William Harper ◽  
Nader A. Al-Otaibi ◽  
Abdulaziz N. Ababtain ◽  
Thomas Bubenik ◽  
Husain M. Al-Muslim

Owned by the Saudi Arabian Government, Saudi Aramco is a fully-integrated, global petroleum enterprise and a world leader in exploration and producing, refining, distribution, shipping and marketing. The company manages the largest proven reserves of conventional crude and the fourth-largest gas reserves in the world. The company runs a vast network of pipelines transporting oil, gas and refined products to processing plants, refineries, export terminals and other customers all over the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Saudi Aramco maintains its commitment to supply gas to the continuously growing local markets by implementing latest technologies and state of the art engineering solutions. Since 2009, and as a result of launching an Electromagnetic Acoustic Transducer (EMAT) In-Line Inspection (ILI) Program, Saudi Aramco has discovered Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) defects in a number of its pipelines. Saudi Aramco built on ASME B31.8S criteria for identifying SCC susceptible segments to prioritize its network to manage the utilization of the EMAT technology. The criteria were based on pipeline operating parameters, environment, age and condition. An Extensive Field Verification program was put in action that illustrated the capabilities of the EMAT ILI tools. (Saudi Aramco’s ILI program included a few additional runs of Ultrasound Crack Detection Tool, UTCD, as well). This paper discusses in more detail how the Study Team enhanced the ASME B31.8S prioritization criteria and the major findings and highlights realized from this activity. A statistical evaluation of the data compiled in the 1st phase of the comprehensive study was conducted along with the literature review. The Study Team used logistic regressions[1,2] to identify factors that increase or decrease the likelihood that cracking is present. The trends that were identified relate to coating type, pipe grade, pipeline age, diameter, thickness, metal loss, cathodic protection (CP) level, slope, and pipe type. The Study Team used the findings to profile crack susceptibility in the pipelines found with SCC and for the Saudi Aramco pipeline network as a whole to identify pipelines susceptible to cracking to include in the future ILI runs.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document