Effective Mass of Fluid for Rocking Motion of Flat-Bottom Cylindrical Tanks

Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Toru Segawa

In analyzing the rocking motion of the flat-bottom cylindrical tanks subjected to severe earthquakes, the effective mass of fluid for the rocking motion and its moment inertia around the pivoting bottom edge of the tank would be indispensable dynamical properties, because they couples the fluid-shell interaction motion, the so-called bulging motion, with the rocking motion. This paper quantifies them based on the equilibrium of the fluid pressure and inertia force accompanying the angular acceleration acting on the pivoting bottom edge of the tank. Employing a general mathematical solution for the fluid pressure that can calculate either fully or partially uplifted tank bottom, this paper presents mathematical formulae of the effective mass of fluid for the rocking motion and its moment inertia. These quantities are given by an explicit function of dimensional variables of the tank but with Fourier series. For designer’s convenience, the effective moment inertia and effective mass of fluid for the rocking motion and its center of gravity from the pivoting bottom edge are normalized accordingly and are depicted on diagrams.

2016 ◽  
Vol 138 (5) ◽  
Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Yukihiro Katayama

This study proposes the use of a slice model consisting of a set of thin rectangular tanks for evaluating the masses of fluid contributing to the rocking motion of cylindrical tanks; the effective mass of fluid for rocking motion, that for rocking–bulging interaction, effective moment inertia of fluid for rocking motion and its centroid. They are mathematically or numerically quantified, normalized, tabulated, and depicted as functions of the aspect of tanks for different values of the ratio of the uplift width of the tank bottom plate to the diameter of tank for the designer's convenience.


Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Yukihiro Katayama

Accurate and easy calculation of the mass of fluid contributing to the rocking motion of cylindrical tanks with partial uplift of bottom plate, which is the effective mass of fluid for rocking motion, that for rocking-bulging interaction, effective moment inertia of fluid for rocking motion and their centroid, is proposed. Asymmetric deformation of the tank bottom plate due to crescent-like uplift is used to put quantification of the masses away from rigorous treatments. This study considers the cylindrical tank as a set of thin rectangular tanks, so-called a slice model, and puts them perpendicular to the rotational axis of the tank rock motion. Then solve a boundary-value problem of each slice model specified by uplift of the tank bottom plate and its location, the mass of fluid contributing to rocking of cylindrical tanks is quantified as the sum of that of each slice model. Values of the effective mass of fluid for rocking motion, that for rocking-bulging interaction, effective moment inertia of fluid for rocking motion and their centroid are tabulated and depicted as a function of the aspect of tanks for different values of the ratio of the uplift width of the tank bottom plate to the diameter of tank.


2009 ◽  
Vol 132 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Yoshinori Ando

To protect flat-bottom cylindrical tanks against severe damage from uplift motion, accurate evaluation of accompanying fluid pressures is indispensable. This paper presents a mathematical solution for evaluating the fluid pressure on a rigid flat-bottom cylindrical tank in the same manner as the procedure outlined and discussed previously by the authors (Taniguchi, T., and Ando, Y., 2010, “Fluid Pressures on Unanchored Rigid Rectangular Tanks Under Action of Uplifting Acceleration,” ASME J. Pressure Vessel Technol., 132(1), p. 011801). With perfect fluid and velocity potential assumed, the Laplace equation in cylindrical coordinates gives a continuity equation, while fluid velocity imparted by the displacement (and its time derivatives) of the shell and bottom plate of the tank defines boundary conditions. The velocity potential is solved with the Fourier–Bessel expansion, and its derivative, with respect to time, gives the fluid pressure at an arbitrary point inside the tank. In practice, designers have to calculate the fluid pressure on the tank whose perimeter of the bottom plate lifts off the ground like a crescent in plan view. However, the asymmetric boundary condition given by the fluid velocity imparted by the deformation of the crescent-like uplift region at the bottom cannot be expressed properly in cylindrical coordinates. This paper examines applicability of a slice model, which is a rigid rectangular tank with a unit depth vertically sliced out of a rigid flat-bottom cylindrical tank with a certain deviation from (in parallel to) the center line of the tank. A mathematical solution for evaluating the fluid pressure on a rigid flat-bottom cylindrical tank accompanying the angular acceleration acting on the pivoting bottom edge of the tank is given by an explicit function of a dimensional variable of the tank, but with Fourier series. It well converges with a few first terms of the Fourier series and accurately calculates the values of the fluid pressure on the tank. In addition, the slice model approximates well the values of the fluid pressure on the shell of a rigid flat-bottom cylindrical tank for any points deviated from the center line. For the designers’ convenience, diagrams that depict the fluid pressures normalized by the maximum tangential acceleration given by the product of the angular acceleration and diagonals of the tank are also presented. The proposed mathematical and graphical methods are cost effective and aid in the design of the flat-bottom cylindrical tanks that allow the uplifting of the bottom plate.


Author(s):  
Teruhiro Nakashima ◽  
Tomoyo Taniguchi

The rocking motion of tanks due to earthquakes causes the large uplift deformation of the tank bottom plate that has been considered to contribute to the various damages of the tanks. For analyzing the uplift displacement of the tank bottom plate statically and precisely, this paper develops a shell element, ring element and spring element partially attached to the ring element. These elements are defined as a semi-analytical finite element. Fourier series give its circumferential displacement function, while the polynomial gives its radial displacement function. In addition, the ring element can deal with effects of the large deformation, while the spring element enables to express the partial contact between the tank bottom plate and foundation. On the other hand, the loads considered are dead load, hydro-pressure and inertia force due to earthquakes acceleration as well as dynamic pressure of fluid induced by bulging and rocking motion of the tank. The numerical analyses model of the LNG Storage Tank was created using the semi-analytical finite elements shown here, and the uplift displacement of the tank bottom plate accompanying the tank rocking motion was calculated with the static analyses. For evaluating analytical accuracy of the proposed method, numerical results of the proposed method are compared with that of the explicit FE Analysis.


Author(s):  
Teruhiro Nakashima ◽  
Tomoyo Taniguchi

For analyzing the uplift displacement of the tank bottom plate statically and precisely, this paper develops a shell element, ring element and spring element partially attached to the ring element. These elements are defined as a semi-analytical finite element. Moreover in analyzing uplift of the tank bottom plate precisely, the ring element can deal with effects of the large deformation, while the spring element enables to express the partial contact between the tank bottom plate and foundation. Dead load, hydro-pressure and inertia force due to earthquakes acceleration as well as dynamic pressure of fluid induced by bulging and rocking motions of the tank are applied statically. Comparison of results by the proposed method and that computed by the explicit FE Analysis reveals that the accurate uplift displacement is not obtained until all physical conditions involved in the tank rocking motion and the inward deformation of the tank shell is properly considered.


Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Takumi Shirasaki

Flat-bottom cylindrical shell tanks may rock and have a crescent-like uplift part in the bottom plate at the event of a severe earthquake. Effects of the deformed tank bottom plate on the fluid pressure on the cylindrical tank have not been, however, quantified yet. Since the crescent-like uplift part appears eccentrically on the periphery of the tank bottom plate, its mathematical treatment would be troublesome. Regarding a cylindrical tank as a set of pieces of a thin rectangular tank with a deformed bottom plate that correspond radially sliced parts of the cylindrical tank with the crescent-like uplift part in the bottom plate, this paper defines the fluid pressure on the cylindrical tank by calculating that on the rectangular tank. For designer’s convenience, the fluid pressure computed are normalized and depicted in accordance with the aspect of the cylindrical tank and the uplift ratio of the tank bottom plate.


2009 ◽  
Vol 132 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Yoshinori Ando

Although uplift motion of flat-bottom cylindrical shell tanks has been considered to contribute toward various damages to the tanks, the mechanics were not fully understood. As well as uplift displacement of the tanks, fluid pressure accompanying the uplift motion of the tanks may play an important role in the cause of the damage. An accurate estimate of the fluid pressure induced by the uplift motion of the tanks is indispensable in protecting the tanks against destructive earthquakes. As a first step of a series of research, this study mathematically derives the fluid pressure on a rigid rectangular tank with a unit depth accompanying angular acceleration, which acts on a pivoting bottom edge. The rectangular tank employed herein is equivalent to a thin slice of the central vertical cross section of a rigid flat-bottom cylindrical shell tank. Assuming a perfect fluid and velocity potential, a continuity equation is given by the Laplace equation in Cartesian coordinates. The fluid velocities accompanying the motions of the walls and bottom plate constitute the boundary conditions. Since this problem is set as a parabolic partial differential equation of the Neumann problem, the velocity potential is solved with the Fourier-cosine expansion. The derivative of the velocity potential with respect to time gives the fluid pressure at an arbitrary point inside the tank. A mathematical solution for evaluating the fluid pressure accompanying the angular acceleration acting on the pivoting bottom edge of the tank is given by an explicit function of a dimensional variable of the tank, but with the Fourier series. The proposed mathematical solution well converges with a few first terms of the Fourier series. Values of the fluid pressure computed by the explicit finite element (FE) analysis well agrees with those by the proposed mathematical solution. For the designers’ convenience, diagrams that depict the fluid pressures normalized by the maximum tangential acceleration given by the product of the angular acceleration and diagonals of the tank are also presented. Consequently, the mathematical solution given by the Fourier series converges easily and provides accurate evaluation of the fluid pressures on a rigid rectangular tank accompanying the angular acceleration acting on the pivoting bottom edge. Irregularity in the fluid pressure distribution increases as the tank becomes taller.


Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi

In experimental and analytical studies of the rocking response of a circular cylindrical tank under the action of the purely horizontal and translational ground motion, the author analogically quantified the mass of fluid contributing to both bulging and rocking motion of the tank. It was called “the effective mass of fluid for the rocking-bulging interaction.” Its dynamical role in the rocking motion of the tank was thoroughly investigated. However, applying it to design process requires us to use its rigorous definition. To date, the fluid pressure on the tank induced by the impulsive (= bulging) motion and the rocking motion and their effective masses of fluid for each motion were mathematically defined, respectively. Therefore, this paper tries to define the effective mass of fluid for the rocking-bulging interaction based on the fluid pressure on the tank mathematically. The effective mass of fluid for the rocking-bulging interaction is understood as a part of the effective mass of fluid for the bulging motion that is also under the action of the rotational inertia. The influence of the rotational inertia on the effective mass of fluid for the bulging motion is measured by a ratio of the apparent density of fluid contributing to the rocking motion to the original density of fluid. The distribution of the apparent density of fluid contributing to the rocking-bulging interaction is drawn for the various aspects of tanks. The ratio of the effective mass of fluid for the rocking-bulging interaction to the total mass of fluid of the tank is given as the function of the aspect ratio of the tank and the ratio of the uplift width of the tank bottom.


Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi ◽  
Teruhiro Nakashima ◽  
Daisuke Okui

For the unanchored flat-bottom cylindrical tanks located in the seismic prone area, uplift of the tank bottom plate is inevitable. Besides the work of Nakashima, effects of out-of-plane deformation of the cylindrical shell on uplift of the tank bottom plate have been paid little attention. In analyzing uplift of the tank bottom plate, for design purpose in particular, its effects should be included. First, employing a cylindrical shell tanks with multistage rigid or elastic stiffeners, their uplift responses to the horizontal sinusoidal base acceleration are compared to highlight effects of out-of-plane deformation on uplift of the tank bottom plate. Next, employing the numerical results of the cylindrical shell tank with multistage rigid stiffeners, analytical accuracy of the simplified calculation for evaluating the angular acceleration accompanying the tank rock motion is examined.


2005 ◽  
Vol 127 (4) ◽  
pp. 373-386 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tomoyo Taniguchi

The rocking motion of the tanks is complex and not fully understood. Using model tanks that possess concentric rigid-doughnut-shaped bottom plates, this paper tries to clarify its fundamental mechanics through the analog of rocking motion of rigid bodies. Introducing an effective mass for the internal liquid for rocking motion enables the development of a dynamical system including the rocking-bulging interaction motion and the effective mass of liquid for the interaction motion. Since the base shear and uplift displacement observed during shaking tests match well with computed values, the proposed procedure can explain the mechanics of the rocking motion of the model tanks used herein.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document