Birth Order and Outcome in HLA-Identical Sibling Donor Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplants. Impact of a Sequential Fetomaternal - Maternofetal Cell Transfer?.
Abstract Fetomaternal and maternofetal cell transfer have been described. Their clinical relevance is unknown. We hypothesized that firstborn siblings could tolerize their siblings born thereafter through sequential fetomaternal-maternofetal cell transfer. Hence, stem cell transplants within a family from a firstborn sibling (group A) should result more graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) and worse overall survival than transplants to a firstborn donor (group B). Results of a retrospective single center cohort analysis of 321 HLA-identical sibling donor hemopoietic stem cell transplants showed a survival of 48.3% (+/−10.9%) at 10 years in the group with firstborn donors (group A, 110 patients) as compared to 63.2 (+/−10.6%) in the group with firstborn recipients (group B, 105 patients; p<0.02) and a RR of death after adjustment for other risk factors of 2.6 (CI 1.45–4.66; p<0.001) for the group with firstborn donors. These results support the concept of a clinically relevant tolerizing effect of birth order, possibly mediated by fetomaternal cell transfer in man. Patients characteristics and outcomes Birth Order Donor First Sibling Recipient First Sibling n 110 105 Donor Age median (range) 30.1 (4.9–68) 25.4 (0.4–59.1) p=0.005 Recipient Age median (range) 25.4(3.2–62.1) 30.8 (2.2–63.0) Number of Siblings 2 67 69 n.s. 3 26 22 >3 17 14 Diagnosis n.s. Acute myeloid leukemia n 33 26 Acute lymphoblastic leukemia n 24 24 Chronic myeloid leukemia n 23 23 Lymphoproliferative disorders n 14 13 Severe aplastic anemia n 11 12 Myelodysplastic syndromes n 5 7 Stem Cell Source n.s. Bone Marrow n 71 73 PBSCT n 39 32 Conditioning n.s. With totoal body irradiation n 18 22 Without total body irradiation n 92 83 Outcomes Survival at 10 yrs % 48.3 63.2 p<0.02 Relapse at 3 yrs. % 26 20 n.s. Acute GvHD p=0.017 < Grade II n 46 61 >= Grade II n 64 44 Chronic GvHD n.s. none n 28 30 n.a. n 29 17 Limited n 32 30 Extensive n 21 23 Figure 1: Kaplan Meyer estimate of cumulative survival of groups A(firstborn donor: gray line) and B (firstborn recipient: black line). + indicates censored patient. Figure 1:. Kaplan Meyer estimate of cumulative survival of groups A(firstborn donor: gray line) and B (firstborn recipient: black line). + indicates censored patient.