Human Nephropathy Related to Ochratoxin a in Tunisia

Mammalian animal toxicity of ochratoxin A (OTA) has focused largely in the past half-century on pigs because of initial recognition of it as a principal cause of intermittent growth suppression and renal disease caused by mouldy feed. Subsequent classical toxicology has used laboratory rodents because renal pathology in pigs raised questions concerning possible involvement in the human idiopathic bilateral renal atrophy of Balkan endemic nephropathy for which OTA was a focus of attention for human nephropathy through 1980s and into 2000s. Emphasis on human nephropathy has more recently concerned the plant metabolite aristolochic acid. Recognition that agricultural management can often minimise food and feed-stuff spoilage by OTA-producing Aspergilli and Penicillia has moderated some of the risks for animals. Legislation for human food safety combined with sophisticated analysis generally provides safety in the developed world. Chronic experimental exposure of male rats, in the absence of clinical dis-ease, specifically causes renal cancer. The possibility of this as a unique model for the human has generated considerable experimental evidence which may be more directly relevant for carcinogenesis in the complex kidney than that obtained from biochemical toxicities in vitro. Nevertheless, there does not appear to be any case of human renal or urinary tract cancer for which there is verified etiological proof for causation by OTA, contrary to much claim in the literature. To contribute to such debate, histopathology review of OTA/rat renal cancers, augmented where appropriate by immune profiles, has been completed for all remaining tumours in our research archive. Overall consistency of positivity for vimentin, is matched with occasional positives either for CD10 or the cytokeratin MNF 116. The current situation is discussed. Suggestion that OTA could cause human testicular cancer has also been challenged as unsupported by any experimental findings in rats, where the Leydig cell tumour immune profile does not match that of human germ cell neoplasms.

Download Full-text

Ochratoxin a and human chronic nephropathy in Tunisia: is the situation endemic?

Human & Experimental Toxicology ◽

10.1191/0960327103ht328oa ◽

2003 ◽

Vol 22 (2) ◽

pp. 77-84 ◽

Cited By ~ 66

Author(s):

Salwa Abid ◽

Wafa Hassen ◽

Abdellatif Achour ◽

Habib Skhiri ◽

Khira Maaroufi ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Kidney Disease ◽

Ochratoxin A ◽

Healthy Subjects ◽

Balkan Endemic Nephropathy ◽

Causative Role ◽

The Balkans ◽

Endemic Nephropathy ◽

Interstitial Nephropathy ◽

End Stage ◽

Human Nephropathy

Ochratoxin A (OTA) is a nephrotoxic mycotoxin that is being increasingly considered as the main causal agent of Balkan endemic nephropathy (BEN), a fatal kidney disease associated with the end stage of urothelial tumours. However, despite the considerable amount of data, it is still controversial whether OTA plays a causative or only a subordinate role in the induction of this human nephropathy. Tunisia for years had to confront a very similar human nephropathy, which is tentatively called chronic interstitial nephropathy of unknown cause. This study tends firstly to consolidate the suspected link between this Tunisian chronic interstitial nephropathy (CIN) of unknown cause and the presence of OTA in the blood and food of such patients, and second to enlighten the endemic character of this particular nephropathy. Therefore, in four consecutive inquiries, performed within the period 1991-2000, blood and food OTA contaminations were assayed and compared for 954 nephropathy patients and 205 healthy subjects from the Tunisian general population. This survey was also designed to show that, although the whole population is likely to be exposed to OTA, specific people living in conditions showing similarities with the Balkans do have a kidney disease apparently linked to ochratoxin in food. The results showed that the highest incidences were found in patients with CIN of unknown cause. Indeed, the percentages of OTA-positive samples ranged from 93% to 100%, whereas it was only from 62% to 82% in healthy subjects. Mean OTA concentrations were also higher in patients with CIN of unknown cause than in controls (44.4±-19 mg/L to 55.6±-19 mg/L as opposed to 1.22±-1.2 mg/L to 3.35±-2.32 mg/L, respectively). This study emphasizes further the implication of OTA on this particular human nephropathy and underlines the probable causative role of OTA in the onset of this disease. It is important to note that the highest levels of food OTA contamination were found in the group presenting with CIN of unknown cause, indicating that, similar to the case in the Balkans, people are exposed to OTA essentially by their food.

Download Full-text