This chapter juxtaposes Indigenous and non-Indigenous ways of enumerating Indigeneity on record, both on paper and on vinyl, which reveal two projects with very different means for very different ends. The chapter begins with an outline of cacophonous colonial structures and paradigms of containment and measurement that continue to vex notions of “audible Indigeneity,” which informs notions of who does or does not “count” as Indigenous. Whereas much of an early twentieth-century ethno/musicological archive was driven by a colonial savior logic known as “salvage ethnography,” an examination of Cupiit-led and Yupiit-centered archives reveal significantly more expansive performances of mid-century Indigeneity. This examination of family- and community-based gospel, country, and folk music archives—featuring recordings by the Shavings Family Band, John Angaiak, and Joe Paul—argues for a densification of deeply embedded archival logics, methods, and theories that currently inform the enumerative conventions of American music historiography. Put another way, this chapter’s core questions include “who is counting (and using what logics)?” and “who decides who counts (as Indigenous)?”