Female choice can explain the fertilization pattern in oaks

We extend a two-step lottery model of Craft et al. to test the hypothesis that oak trees pursue a form of within-flower female choice to increase the diversity of fathers. Oak trees produce six ovules per flower while maturing just one acorn. When assuming a random ovule selection - which is a natural assumption in the absence of other hypotheses - observed fertilization patterns in oaks cannot be explained: long-distance fertilization is unusually common, even as nearby oak trees may be absent as pollen donors. Our model demonstrates how producing multiple ovules per flower permits selection for rare, distant fathers. The number of ovules per flower that maximizes paternal diversity increases with the number of trees. We introduce a cost function for ovule production for which six ovules per flower balance these costs with the benefits of diversifying fathers. Using data from two published field studies, 7 of 8 investigated maternal oaks had actual paternal diversity indices (average diversity index of 15.42) that fit the female choice hypothesis (estimated diversity of 14.66) significantly better than assuming a random selection from the six available ovules (estimated diversity of 7.649). A third field study permitted us to compare paternity by distance classes for two maternal trees. Both fit the female choice model better than random ovule selection.

Geographic Patterns In Pollen Production In The Plant Ring Species Euphorbia tithymaloides In The Caribbean

Abstract—We examine investment in male function in the context of geography and floral morphology in the plant ring species Euphorbia tithymaloides, which colonized the Caribbean from Mexico/Guatemala along two fronts that roughly correspond to the Greater and the Lesser Antilles and that meet in the vicinity of the Anegada Passage. Our results on investment in pollen relative to ovule production are consistent with E. tithymaloides relying on pollinators for reproduction across its range in the Caribbean. We document a geographic pattern of reduction in anther number and pollen:ovule ratios in populations of E. tithymaloides towards the Anegada Passage, which is consistent with a possible geographic transition towards a mixed breeding system where selfing has increased importance in this area where its two expansion fronts meet. The reduction in pollen production is correlated with inflorescence morphology, which converges to relatively shorter cyathia towards the Anegada Passage along both fronts. We discuss alternative scenarios and potential drivers of the patterns we document.

Ovule and seed production patterns in relation to flower size variations in actinomorphic and zygomorphic flower species

Zygomorphic flower species tend to show lower flower size variation than actinomorphic flower species. Have these differences also brought an association in ovule and seed production that has arisen due to natural selection in these species? Flowers were collected from 29 actinomorphic and 20 zygomorphic flower species, and fruits were collected from 21 actinomorphic and 14 zygomorphic flower species in Miyagi and Aomori prefectures, in Japan. The coefficient of variations (CVs) of flower sizes, mean ovule sizes of flowers, ovule numbers of flowers and mean seed sizes of fruits were calculated. The CV of flower sizes was marginally different between the floral symmetry types; tending to be lower in the zygomorphic flower species than in the actinomorphic flower species. The CVs of mean ovule sizes and ovule numbers of flowers increased with increase in the CV of flower sizes in the actinomorphic flower species but not in the zygomorphic flower species. Mean ovule number of flowers tends to increase with increase in mean flower size in the actinomorphic flower species but not in the zygomorphic flower species. The degrees in variations in ovule size and number of flowers were influenced by the interaction of floral symmetry type and flower size variation, suggesting that floral symmetry also has brought an evolutionary association in ovule production by flowers.

Evolution towards minimum ovule size? Ovule size variations and the relative sizes of ovules to seeds

Background and Aims Is there selection minimizing the costs of ovule production? Such selection should lead to a smaller ovule size in relation to seed size and, at the same time, smaller variation in ovule size within plants, the latter because the minimum structures and resources for functioning of ovules should be the same among ovules. Additionally, within species, ovule size should not depend on the plant’s resource status. Methods To confirm these predictions, we examined ovule and seed production for a variety of species. Key Results Among the 27 species studied, we found a significant negative dependence of the species mean of the coefficient of variation for plant ovule size on the ratio of the mean species seed size/mean species ovule size. Thus, the smaller the ovule size as compared with seed size, the smaller the degree of variation in ovule size. Among the 49 species studied, only two species showed significant positive dependence of mean ovule size on plant size. Although larger plants should have greater resources for ovule production, selection has not enhanced the production of large ovules in most species. Conclusions These results suggest that there is selection minimizing the costs of ovule production.

Pollination unpredictability and ovule number in a South-Andean Proteaceae along a rainfall gradient

Pollen limitation occurs frequently in plant populations and, as result, many ovules are wasted. One possible adaptive explanation posits that ovule overproduction represents a ‘bet-hedging’ strategy against pollination inefficiency. This hypothesis is supported by comparative evidence showing that unpredictability in pollen receipt is positively associated with an increasing number of ovules per flower across species. Yet, this proposition has not been tested at the intraspecific level, where natural selection operates. Here, we evaluated the relationship between pollination unpredictability, considering both pollination quantity and quality, and number of ovules per flower, across 16 populations of the south-Andean generalist treelet Embothrium coccineum J.R.Forster and G.Forst from north-western Patagonia, which occurs along a west–east gradient of decreasing rainfall. Despite sizable variation in mean number of ovules per flower, we found no increase in ovule production with increasing pollination unpredictability across populations. Instead, we found that mean number of ovules per flower decreased with decreasing rainfall. Therefore, in this species, there was no support for the proposal that ovule overproduction represents a bet-hedging strategy against unpredictable pollen receipt. Rather, the number of ovules per flower seems to be conditioned primarily by resource availability.