In response to ecological disturbances, sedge species like Carex pensylvanica form dense monocultures on the forest floor. These “sedge mats” have been shown to severely inhibit plant growth, and limit understory species diversity. In recent years, concern has grown that they may also be restricting the regeneration of economically valuable tree species like sugar maple through belowground competition. To determine if and how Carex pensylvanica may be impacting tree seedling growth through belowground competition I located and exclosed 44 tree seedlings in areas of representatively dense sedge at two forest sites at the Queen’s University Biological Station. I removed sedge from half the plots, and measured soil resource availability and seedling growth response at all plots throughout the growing season. I predicted that sedge would negatively impact the growth of tree seedlings by decreasing the availability of soil resources. I found that the presence of sedge did not affect seedling growth over one growing season, but that it did impact soil resource availability by increasing the availability of surface soil moisture and decreasing the availability of soil nitrate, changes which may have implications for seedling growth beyond the single growing season studied. My results were also site specific, indicating that location is important when managing sedge impact on tree regeneration. Understanding the impact of sedge on tree seedling regeneration is important for predicting changes in the trajectory of forest communities and for informing the management of economically valuable species like sugar maple.