Did the BOOG 2013–08, which examines the value of omission of the sentinel lymph node in cT1-2 breast cancer treated with BCT, induce a change in axillary staging and treatment?

2020 ◽  
Vol 138 ◽  
pp. S47
Author(s):  
E. Colier ◽  
S. Pessers ◽  
R. Vos ◽  
M. Smidt ◽  
L. van Roozendaal
2013 ◽  
Vol 31 (31_suppl) ◽  
pp. 117-117
Author(s):  
Archana Radhakrishnan ◽  
Paula Silverman ◽  
Robert R. Shenk ◽  
Cheryl L. Thompson

117 Background: Racial disparities in outcomes continue to persist amongst breast cancer (BC) patients (pts). Standard of care for the surgical evaluation of early BC has changed from axillary lymph node dissection being recommended for axillary staging to sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) for clinically node-negative pts. SLNB, however, can be deferred if findings would not alter treatment plans. The goal of this study is to determine if SLNB rates differ by race, age, insurer, community vs academic setting or surgeon. Causes contributing to disparities will be considered. Methods: Pts undergoing primary surgery for early stage BC from 2010-2011 at our academic teaching hospital and two affiliated community medical centers were identified from the tumor registry. Data abstracted included demographics, insurance type, medical center and surgeon. For pts without SLNB, clinical information was confirmed with medical record review. Unadjusted comparison of factors for pts who did and did not have SLNB was evaluated with a t-test or chi square test. Logistic regression modeling assessed significance of demographic and clinical factors predicting SLNB. Results: 499 pts were identified; 114 (23%) were black, 373 (75%) white, and 12 (2%) others/unknown race. SLNB was performed in 443 (89%) of total pts, without racial differences (86% of black and 89% of white pts (p=0.31) had SLNB). Average age of pts who had SLNB was younger (60.4) than those who did not (76.3) (p<0.01). As compared to those with managed care insurance (97%) or Medicaid (91%), only 78% of Medicare pts had SLNB (p<0.01). There was no statistical difference in SLNB rates between academic and community medical centers or by surgeon. Chart review determined that the standard of care was met in 55/56 pts who did not have SLNB; reasons for no SLNB include advanced age (range 79-95), in-breast recurrences, and positive nodes pre-operatively. Conclusions: Utilization rates of SLNB did not differ between black and white BC pts. Differences were seen based on age and insurer. Although only 89% of pts had SLNB, careful evaluation for reasons reveals medically appropriate treatment in almost all cases. These results suggest cautionary interpretation of large database findings.


2014 ◽  
Vol 22 ◽  
pp. 54 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Brackstone ◽  
G.G. Fletcher ◽  
I.S. Dayes ◽  
Y. Madarnas ◽  
S.K. SenGupta ◽  
...  

QuestionsIn female patients with locally advanced breast cancer (labc) and good response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy (nact), including endocrine therapy, what is the role of breast-conserving surgery (bcs) compared with mastectomy?In female patients with labc, a. is radiotherapy (rt) indicated for those who have undergone mastectomy? b. does locoregional rt, compared with breast or chest wall rt alone, result in a higher survival rate and lower recurrence rates? c. is rt indicated for those achieving a pathologic complete response (pcr) to nact?In female patients with labc who receive nact, is the most appropriate axillary staging procedure sentinel lymph node biopsy (slnb) or axillary dissection? Is slnb indicated before nact rather than at the time of surgery?How should female patients with labc that does not respond to initial nact be treated?MethodsThis guideline was developed by Cancer Care Ontario’s Program in Evidence-Based Care (pebc) and the Breast Cancer Disease Site Group (dsg). A systematic review was prepared based on literature searches conducted using the medline and embase databases for the period 1996 to December 11, 2013.Guidelines were located from that search and from the Web sites of major guideline organizations. The working group drafted recommendations based on the systemic review. The systematic review and recommendations were then circulated to the Breast Cancer dsg and the pebc Report Approval Panel for internal review; the revised document underwent external review. The full three-part evidence series can be found on the Cancer Care Ontario Web site.RecommendationsFor most patients with labc, modified radical mastectomy should be considered the standard of care. For some patients with noninflammatory labc, bcs can be considered on a case-by-case basis when the surgeon deems that the disease can be fully resected and the patient expresses a strong preference for breast preservation.For patients with labc, rt after mastectomy is recommended.It is recommended that, after bcs or mastectomy, patients with labc receive locoregional rt encompassing the breast or chest wall and local node-bearing areas.It is recommended that postoperative rt remain the standard of care for patients with labc who achieve pcr to nact.It is recommended that axillary dissection remain the standard of care for axillary staging in labc, with the judicious use of slnb in patients who are advised of the limitations of the current data.Although slnb either before or after nact is technically feasible, the data are insufficient to make any recommendation about the optimal timing of slnb with respect to nact. Limited data suggest higher sentinel lymph node identification rates and lower false negative identification rates when slnb is conducted before nact; however, those data must be balanced against the requirement for two operations if slnb is not performed at the time of resection of the main tumour.It is recommended that patients receiving neoadjuvant anthracycline–taxane-based therapy (or other sequential regimens) whose tumours do not respond to the initial agent or agents, or who experience disease progression, be expedited to the next agent or agents of the regimen.For patients who, in the opinion of the treating physician, fail to respond or progress on firstline nact, several therapeutic options can be considered, including second-line chemotherapy, hormonal therapy (if appropriate), rt, or immediate surgery (if technically feasible). Treatment should be individualized through discussion at a multidisciplinary case conference, considering tumour characteristics, patient factors and preferences, and risk of adverse effects.It is recommended that prospective randomized clinical trials be designed for patients with labc who fail to respond to nact so that more definitive treatment recommendations can be developed.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document