Root Cause Analysis of the Unexpected Behaviour of a Flaked Material Under Irradiation and Transferability to the Doel 3/Tihange 2 Reactor Pressure Vessels

Author(s):  
Evy De Bruycker ◽  
Séverine De Vroey ◽  
Xavier Hallet ◽  
Jacqueline Stubbe ◽  
Steve Nardone

During the 2012 outage at Doel 3 (D3) and Tihange 2 (T2) Nuclear Power Plants (NPP), a large number of nearly-laminar indications were detected mainly in the lower and upper core shells. The D3/T2 shells are made from solid casts that were pierced and forged. Restart authorization in 2013 was accompanied by a number of “mid-term” requirements, to be completed during the first operating cycle after the restart. One of these requirements was the mechanical testing of irradiated specimens containing hydrogen flakes. These tests showed unexpected results regarding the shift in the Reference Temperature for Nil Ductility Transition (RTNDT) of the flaked material VB395 (Steam Generator shell rejected because of flakes) after irradiation. This paper presents the root cause analysis of this unexpected behaviour and its transferability (or not) to the D3/T2 Reactor Pressure Vessels (RPVs). A mechanistic and a manufacturing based approach were used, aiming at identifying the microstructural mechanisms responsible for the atypical embrittlement of VB395 and evaluating the plausibility of these mechanisms in the D3/T2 RPVs. This work was based on expert’s opinions, literature data and test results. Both flaked and unflaked samples have been investigated in irradiated and non-irradiated condition. All hydrogen-related mechanisms were excluded as root cause of the unexpected behaviour of VB395. Two possible mechanisms at the basis of the atypical embrittlement of VB395 were identified, but are still open to discussion. These mechanisms could be linked to the specific manufacturing history of the rejected VB395 shell. Since the larger than predicted shift in transition temperature after irradiation of VB395 is not linked with the hydrogen flaking and since none of the specific manufacturing history features that are possible root causes are reported for the D3/T2 RPVs, the D3/T2 shells should not show the unexpected behaviour observed in VB395.

Author(s):  
Chen Qiang ◽  
Han Ning ◽  
Chen Weihan ◽  
Che Yinhui

Pipe rupture in the Condensate Extraction system (CEX) of nuclear power plants will lead to high oxygen content in the secondary circuit and therefore exacerbates equipment and pipeline corrosion. At the same time, there is a risk of loss of vacuum in the system, which has a direct impact on the safe and stable operation of nuclear power plants and will affect the economic benefits. In this paper, Equipment Failure Root Cause Analysis (ERCA) methodology is employed combined with metallography analysis (SEM analysis, XRD) and finite element simulation analysis, to investigate the root cause for drainage pipeline rupture in CEX System of Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR). Detailed analysis process of ERCA was introduced including RCA project establishment, data collection, failure modes analysis and so on. The most probable failure mode is pointed out through the investigation and evidence analyzed. It suggests that the improper design and the installation of limiting orifice plate should be the root cause. And corresponding corrective actions are put forward in details to prevent the recurrence.


Author(s):  
Pierre Dulieu ◽  
Valéry Lacroix

During the 2012 outage at Doel 3 and Tihange 2 Nuclear Power Plants, specific ultrasonic in-service inspections revealed a large number of quasi-laminar indications in the base metal of the reactor pressure vessels, mainly in the lower and upper core shells. The observed indications could subsequently be attributed to hydrogen flaking induced during the component manufacturing process. As a consequence, a Flaw Acceptability Assessment had to be performed as a part of the Safety Case demonstrating the fitness-for-service of these units. In that framework, detailed analyses using eXtended Finite Element Method were conducted to model the specific character of hydrogen flakes. Their quasi-laminar orientation as well as their high density required setting up 3D multi-flaws model accounting for flaw interaction. These calculations highlighted that even the most penalizing flaw configurations are harmless in terms of structural integrity despite the consideration of higher degradation of irradiated material toughness.


Author(s):  
Che Yinhui ◽  
Guan Jianjun ◽  
Zu Shuai ◽  
Chen Qiang

Electric feedwater pump is an important feedwater equipment of nuclear power plants, and its reliability is directly related to the safe and steady operation of nuclear power plants and also economic benefits. In fact, corrosion of electric feedwater pump motor shaft occurs repeatedly, and even bearing shell in the motor can be burned out happen sometimes. This text sets out to analyze the cause of corrosion of electric feedwater pump motor shaft, identify the root cause, and further work out pertinent corrective actions based on the structure of the feedwater pump.


Author(s):  
Hiroshi Matsuzawa

There are 53 (fifty-three) nuclear power plants (both PWR and BWR type) are now under operating in Japan, and the oldest plant has been operating more than thirty years. These plants will be operated until sixty years for operation periods, and will be verified the integrity for assessment of nuclear plants for every ten years in Japan. Reactor Pressure Vessels (RPVs) are required to evaluate the reduction of fracture toughness and the increase of the reference temperature in the transition region. As the operating period will be longer, the prediction for these material properties will be more important. Recently the domestic prediction formula of embrittlement was revised based on the database of domestic plant surveillance test results for thirty years olds as the JEAC4201-2007 [7]. The adequacy for this prediction formula using for sixty year periods is verified by use of the results of the material test reactors (MTRs), but the effects of the accelerated irradiation on embrittlement has not been clear now. So, JNES started the national project, called as “PRE” project on 2005 in order to investigate how flux influences on the ΔRTNDT. In this project the RPV materials irradiated in the actual PWR plant have been re-irradiated in the OECD/Halden test reactor by several different fluxes up to the high fluence region, and the microstructual change for these materials will be investigated in order to make clear the cause of the irradiation embrittlement. In this paper the overall scheme of this project and the summary of the updated results will be presented.


Author(s):  
Guan Jianjun ◽  
Che Yinhui ◽  
Ma Lei

Incident investigation and root cause analysis (RCA) are widely used in nuclear power plant incident investigation and root cause confirmation. In this paper, based on the analysis literature reviews of root cause investigation of related incidents in IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency), Europe and the United States, the analysis methods and techniques or tools of root causes in the world are studied, the incident investigation and analysis methods and techniques for root causes are analyzed and summarized. Through a comparison of various analysis methods and relevant application techniques and tools, differences between these root cause analysis techniques and tools are elaborated in terms of both concept and applicable application. In addition, application of RCA analysis methods and techniques is also briefed based on domestic RCA application practices.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document