REPLY BY D. RANKIN TO THE DISCUSSION BY J. T. WEAVER
I am indebted to Weaver if he has indeed clarified certain points which I had previously considered to be obvious. Cagniard (1953) states explicitly the magnitude of the wavelengths in free space and it is further implicit in the work of Rankin (1962) that it is indeed this same electromagnetic field which is being considered. The plane wave aspect of the problem arises from the extent of and not the distance from the source so that truly it is the induction field and not the radiation field that is under discussion. I had believed, until this note by Weaver, that d’Erceville and Kunetz (1962) also considered a plane wave incident on the earth and in fact that I was merely following both Cagniard and d’Erceville and Kunetz in this matter. The consistency of the results would tend to confirm this belief.