Attitudes of British Psychiatrists to the Diagnosis of Somatisation Disorder

1993 ◽  
Vol 162 (4) ◽  
pp. 463-466 ◽  
Author(s):  
Julian Stern ◽  
Michael Murphy ◽  
Christopher Bass

A postal questionnaire was sent to 195 senior British psychiatrists who were asked about their attitudes towards the DSM-III-R diagnosis of somatisation disorder (SD) and the ICD-10 diagnosis of multiple somatisation disorder. Of the 148 respondents, 98 (66%) had experience of liaison psychiatry, and these psychiatrists used the diagnosis significantly more often than those without liaison sessions. More than half the respondents perceived SD as both a personality disorder and a mental state disorder, although 27% thought that patients with SD had an undiagnosed physical disease. The marked discrepancy between British and North American psychiatrists in diagnostic practices was perceived to be a consequence of both the difference in health care systems and the interest shown in the disorder by North American psychiatrists, rather than a reflection of genuine differences in prevalence.

2002 ◽  
Vol 181 (6) ◽  
pp. 526-530 ◽  
Author(s):  
Nicola J. Dummett ◽  
Nicola J. Maughan ◽  
Anne Worrall-Davies

BackgroundEarly studies suggested that presentations with unexplained acute abdominal pain were associated with increased long-term rates of hospital attendance and self-harm, especially in women, but few studies were large enough for definitive findings.AimsTo test the hypothesis that such presentations are followed by higher long-term utilisation rates of secondary health care even excluding further abdominal symptoms, and particularly for self-harm, than presentations with acute appendicitis.MethodNew hospital attendance rates, liaison psychiatry attendances and self-harm attendances of patients with normal appendices at emergency appendicectomy were compared with those of appendicitis patients.ResultsAttendance rates of all kinds were significantly higher for normal appendix patients than for appendicitis patients, with equal strengths of finding for males and females.ConclusionsPeople with normal appendices at emergency appendicectomy show higher long-term rates of hospital attendance. This has implications for how these patients are best managed by health care systems.


2019 ◽  
Vol 115 ◽  
pp. 81-95
Author(s):  
Paweł Lenio

SOURCES OF FINANCING OF THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM IN POLAND AND IN ITALYThe study found that the majority of similarities and differences in the legal structure of Polish and Italian sources of financing of health care are the result of the adoption of a specific model of health care, and therefore there are fundamental differences between the catalogues of sources of financing health care in Poland and Italy. The basis for the difference between the Italian and Polish catalogues of sources of financing health care is the obligation of patients to contribute to the costs of the health care system in Italy by paying fees in return for receiving a certain type of service. In the reforms of the Polish and Italian health care systems one can see signs of transferring more and more responsibility to local government units. However, Italian and Polish local government units have no influence on the principles of functioning of the system and the shape of basic sources of financing health care.


2018 ◽  
Vol 4 (Supplement 2) ◽  
pp. 72s-72s
Author(s):  
J . ◽  
V .

Background: Cancer drugs challenge health-care systems because of their high prices. Drugs prices, health-care systems and GDP are no uniform throughout the world. United Kingdom (UK) has a 320% better GDP than Argentina (ARG). Aim: We aimed to compare the prices of cancer drugs in both countries, including originals, generics/copies and biosimilars available in ARG by July 2017. Methods: We surveyed official list prices per unit at ex-factory price level of 52 original cancer drugs in UK and ARG. Drugs were grouped in low (LPD) (10), medium (MPD) (7) and high prices (HPD) (35). We included prices of generics/copies (74 generics brands of 7 LPD and 46 generics brands of 6 MPD and HPD) and biosimilars (2) available in ARG and compared with those from originals. Surveyed prices did not include negotiated discounts as authorities and third payers use these undiscounted official lists to set health care. We calculated appropriate discounts to equate prices. Results: In ARG the difference of a drug price between generics/copies and originals has an average of 10.6% less for nonoriginals (range +5% to −24%). No nonoriginals drugs cost less than 24% of originals. Great variations of prices (57%) among generics. The difference of price between biosimilars and originals was 13.8% less for biosimilars. The differences of a drug price between UK and ARG showed that: a) LPD prices in ARG were 53% (−39% to +68%) more expensive than in UK, b) 86% of MPD are more expensive in ARG than in UK, with an average of 222% (−49% to +707%), c) 100% of HPD are more expensive in ARG than in UK, with an average of 123% (+8% to +408%). When translating to currency (all in US$) differences were an average of: a) LPD +141 (−353 to +412), b) MPD +1295 (−164 to +2531), and c) HPD +2649 (+471 to +10,359) more expensive in ARG than in UK per unit. Average discounts necessary to equate undiscounted official ARG list to undiscounted official UK list are: LPD 45% (24-64), MPD 71% (60-87), HPD 51% (13-80). Conclusion: a) Our results show great variations in prices between both countries. b) Prices are inversely related to GDP. c) 100% of HPD and 86% of MPD have overprices in ARG respect to UK with an average of 123% and 222% respectively. d) In currency these represent an average overpayment of US$ 2649 and US$ 1295 per unit respectively. e) Appropriate discounts to equate ARG list to UK list should be around 50%–70%. f) In ARG, differences of prices between generics/copies/biosimilars and originals are less than 24%, with an average of 10%–13%. g) By using undiscounted lists there is a high risk of overpayment. Unpublished final prices list may preclude a good decision making process even at physician level, considering that many of MPD and HPD are directed to stage IV noncurative patients with marginal quality of life advantages for some of these treatments. h) Our findings provide an evidence base for policy makers in nonhigh income countries.


1929 ◽  
Vol 25 (5) ◽  
pp. 476-478
Author(s):  
M. M. Gran

The Soviet system, Soviet policy and the principles of Soviet construction in general, and in the field of health care in particular, dramatically and radically changed the principles of organizing the construction of our resorts and resort business. If it were required to demonstrate in the field of health care the difference in the principles, paths and achievements of the prerevolutionary and post-revolutionary periods in the field of health care, if it was necessary to compare two health care systems - capitalist (Western European) and socialist (Russian), then the best and most successful object for comparison than balneology would be hard to find


2020 ◽  
Vol 25 (4) ◽  
pp. 301-316
Author(s):  
Matt Fossey ◽  
Lauren Godier-McBard ◽  
Elspeth A. Guthrie ◽  
Jenny Hewison ◽  
Peter Trigwell ◽  
...  

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to explore the challenges that are experienced by staff responsible for commissioning liaison psychiatry services and to establish if these are shared by other health professionals. Design/methodology/approach Using a mixed-methods design, the findings from a mental health commissioner workshop (n = 12) were used to construct a survey that was distributed to health care professionals using an opportunistic framework (n = 98). Findings Four key themes emerged from the workshop, which was tested using the survey. The importance of secure funding; a better understanding of health care systems and pathways; partnership working and co-production and; access to mental health clinical information in general hospitals. There was broad convergence between commissioners, mental health clinicians and managers, except in relation to gathering and sharing of data. This suggests that poor communication between professionals is of concern. Research limitations/implications There were a small number of survey respondents (n = 98). The sampling used an opportunistic framework that targeted commissioner and clinician forums. Using an opportunistic framework, the sample may not be representative. Additionally, multiple pairwise comparisons were conducted during the analysis of the survey responses, increasing the risk that significant results were found by chance. Practical implications A number of steps were identified that could be applied in practice. These mainly related to the importance of collecting and communicating data and co-production with commissioners in the design, development and monitoring of liaison psychiatry services. Originality/value This is the first study that has specifically considered the challenges associated with the commissioning of liaison psychiatry services.


2004 ◽  
Vol 171 (4S) ◽  
pp. 42-43 ◽  
Author(s):  
Yair Latan ◽  
David M. Wilhelm ◽  
David A. Duchene ◽  
Margaret S. Pearle

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document