Androgen receptor (AR) actions are vital for spermatogenesis. However, in postnatal development male germ cells do not express AR, highlighting its key role in testicular somatic cells. We recently used a Cre-loxP strategy to determine the in vivo requirement of AR DNA-binding in Sertoli cell (SC) function. Transgenic (Tg) mice with Cre expression targeted by SC-specific AMH or Abp promoters were crossed with floxed-Ar (Arflox) mice for Cre-loxP inframe deletion of Ar exon 3, which encodes a zinc finger essential for the DNA-binding domain (DBD). SC-specific mutated ARΔex3 (SCARΔex3) produced infertile AMH.SCARΔex3 and Abp.SCARΔex3 males. Testes from adult homozygous TgCre(+/+) AMH.SCARΔex3 or Abp.SCARΔex3 males were 30% of normal size and exhibited meiotic arrest, whereas testes from hemizygous TgCre(+/–) Abp.SCARΔex3 males were larger (47% normal) with more postmeiotic germ cell development. Despite marked Leydig cell hypertrophy, testicular expression of the adult Leydig marker Hsd3b6 (RT-PCR) and normal intratesticular testosterone levels (LC-MS/MS) in SCARΔex3 males indicated the presence of morphologically distinct but functional adult Leydig cells. SC-specific mutated AR Δex3 was predicted to disrupt classical AR-regulated pathways via loss of direct DNA interaction. Androgen-repressed testicular Ngfr expression (known to be via non-classical AR pathways) was not upregulated in SCARΔex3 testes, suggesting maintenance of a non-classical mechanism independent of AR-DBD. In contrast, SC-specific Rhox5 and Eppin transcription, regulated by divergent or classical androgen-response elements respectively, were both decreased in postnatal SCARΔex3 vs. control testes, demonstrating SC-specific AR function as early as postnatal day 5. However, Rhox5 expression declined dose-dependently, whereas Eppin expression increased, in adult TgCre(+/−) and TgCre(+/+) SCARΔex3 testes, revealing differential temporal control for distinct AR-regulated transcripts. Thus, our SCARΔex3 paradigm displayed dose-dependent TgCre-disruption of meiotic competence and post-meiotic development as well as gene expression, and represents a unique model to selectively differentiate AR-regulated genes.