Abstract
Background
Thoracic epidural analgesia (TEA) has been the traditional option for post-operative pain management for Kausch-Whipple pancreaticoduodenectomy (KWPD) via a ‘reverse L’ incision. An alternative option with inter-pleural analgesia (IPA) has become popular. However, the superior form of analgesia for KWPD regarding analgesic and non-analgesic outcomes is unclear. This study aims to establish if IPA is equivalent to TEA.
Methods
Retrospective study of all patients who underwent KWPD with ‘reverse L’ incision by a single surgeon between February 2014 to June 2016. All received either IPA or TEA post-operatively; patients who had rectus sheath catheter and spinal anaesthesia were excluded. To reduce bias, the Anaesthetist, rather than Surgeon, decided the choice of analgesia based on personal skill. Efficacy regarding analgesia were collected by nursing staff as patient-reported pain severity (mild, moderate or severe). Data were collected from patient case notes and electronic records. This study analysed analgesia efficacy, complications, inotrope use, and intensive treatment unit (ITU) stay.
Results
A total of 40 included in the study. Twenty-two patients had TEA (45% female, median age 68 years) and 18 had IPA (44% female, median age 67 years). Median Charleson Comorbidity Index (CCI) was 5 for both. Patient-reported pain was not statistically different (p = 0.15). We noted more analgesia complications with TEA (not working=4, leakage=2, haemodynamic instability=1, lower limb anaesthesia=1) than IPA (leakage=1; p = 0.027). Eleven (50%) TEA and eight (44%) IPA patients required inotropes. TEA patients required significantly longer duration (median duration 35 VS 18 hours, p = 0.047). Median ITU stay was 3 and 2 days for TEA and IPA patients, respectively.
Conclusions
Both TEA and IPA provide adequate pain relief for KWPD performed via a ‘reversed L’ incision. However, evidence suggests TEA was associated with significantly more analgesia-related complications and longer inotropic requirements. Furthermore, there was also a trend towards ITU stays with TEA. Therefore, we would recommend the use of inter-pleural analgesia over thoracic epidural.
3 - PATIENT REPORTED OUTCOMES AFTER EMERGENCY LAPAROTOMY COMPARING CONTINUOUS RECTUS SHEATH BLOCK AND THORACIC EPIDURAL
