The Business Education of Charismatic Leaders and Good Soldiers

Author(s):  
Sharon E. Norris

This article describes how charismatic leaders inspire followers with a vision of a better future, but attaining that better future is not easy and requires hard work, extra effort, and sacrifice. In challenging organizational environments where crisis is present, one leadership style that emerges has been described as charismatic. Charismatic leaders have a tendency to create good soldiers, a loyal band of followers who engage in organizational citizenship behaviors. These good soldiers encourage others to join the effort to create a better world and achieve goals. The difficulty sets in when charismatic leaders and their good soldiers continually ask for more of their employees, take the spotlight, diminish the contributions of others, and create an environment where the performance of extra-role behaviors becomes the expected norm. When followers are pressured to perform citizenry behaviors, they no longer do so voluntarily, which places stress on employees and eventually dampens enthusiasm and motivation. Business educators preparing the next generation of leaders need to raise awareness of the strengths and possible weaknesses associated with charismatic leadership and organizational citizenship behaviors.

Author(s):  
Sharon E. Norris

This article describes how charismatic leaders inspire followers with a vision of a better future, but attaining that better future is not easy and requires hard work, extra effort, and sacrifice. In challenging organizational environments where crisis is present, one leadership style that emerges has been described as charismatic. Charismatic leaders have a tendency to create good soldiers, a loyal band of followers who engage in organizational citizenship behaviors. These good soldiers encourage others to join the effort to create a better world and achieve goals. The difficulty sets in when charismatic leaders and their good soldiers continually ask for more of their employees, take the spotlight, diminish the contributions of others, and create an environment where the performance of extra-role behaviors becomes the expected norm. When followers are pressured to perform citizenry behaviors, they no longer do so voluntarily, which places stress on employees and eventually dampens enthusiasm and motivation. Business educators preparing the next generation of leaders need to raise awareness of the strengths and possible weaknesses associated with charismatic leadership and organizational citizenship behaviors.


2018 ◽  
Vol 8 (7) ◽  
pp. 51
Author(s):  
Amora Nasser Hamed Mostafa ◽  
Wafaa Abd El-Azeem El-hosany ◽  
Nehad Ezz EL-Din Fekry

Background and objective: Heads of academic departments are the first line leaders who directly influence the quality of their departments, transformational leadership has been demonstrated as an effective leadership style in leading organizations and motivating the subordinates to do more than what is being expected. This study aimed to assess the perception of assistant teaching staff of their leaders’ transformational leadership behaviors and its relation to their organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) in Suez Canal University.Methods: The studied sample was 456 of assistant teaching staff working at 13 faculties in Suez Canal University. Data collected using self-administrated questionnaire consists of two tools: transformational leadership scale, and organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) scale, both likert types rating scale.Results: More than two thirds (65.2%) of the participated assistant teaching staff perceived their leaders as having unsatisfactory transformational leadership behaviors, two thirds (66.4%) of them were satisfied with their organizational citizenship behaviors, and there was significant positive correlation between transformational leadership behaviors and OCBs.Conclusions: There was significant positive correlation between transformational leadership behaviors and OCBs.


Psico-USF ◽  
2015 ◽  
Vol 20 (3) ◽  
pp. 493-504 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alexandra de Oliveira Rodrigues ◽  
Maria Cristina Ferreira

Abstract We investigated the impact of transactional and transformational leadership styles on organizational citizenship behaviors. The sample consisted of 213 workers of both genders who answered the Multifactorial Leadership Scale and the Organizational Citizenship Behaviors (OCB) Scale. The multiple linear regression showed that: the transactional leadership style positively predicted the OCB dimension associated to the creation of a climate favorable to the organization in the external environment; the transformational leadership style positively predicted the dimensions of OCB associated to the creative suggestions related to the system; to the creation of a favorable organizational climate in the external environment; to self-training and to cooperation among colleagues; transformational leadership style showed greater predictive power on OCB than transactional leadership. It was concluded that transformational leaders are more capable to lead their subordinates in order to take actions that go beyond their prescribed roles.


2019 ◽  
Vol 27 (7) ◽  
pp. 15-17

Purpose The authors wanted to analyze their belief that an ethical leadership style in managers would improve both organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) and creative performance (CP) in their employees. Design/methodology/approach To test their hypotheses, the authors collected data from a large multinational company in Pakistan in the consumer goods sector. The HR department allowed the authors to approach the staff directly and ask them to participate. Employees were asked to fill in a questionnaire containing statements about demographics, ELS and PCF. All questionnaires were submitted in English. A total of 500 questionnaires were administered and 248 were completed. Findings The research demonstrated the effect on both organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) and creative performance (CP). The authors showed how psychological contract fulfilment (PCF) was the mediating mechanism that explained the link. Originality/value Managers should pay close attention to the practical implications. It was clear employees paid close attention to their leaders’ attitudes so managers needed to set the right tone. If they showed good behaviour, it encouraged followers to do the same. The research also showed that ethical leaders were better at fulfilling the “psychological contract” of employees. When this was the case, an employee’s sense of commitment was enhanced as they expected their needs to be met in the future.


2015 ◽  
Vol 30 (2) ◽  
pp. 218-232 ◽  
Author(s):  
Paolo Guenzi ◽  
Federico Panzeri

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to more thoroughly investigate the role of organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) in sales force settings and the reason why salespeople should practice OCBs. In fact, in spite of the huge body of literature on OCBs and their impact on performance, some important knowledge gaps still remain to be filled. Inconsistent and unexpected findings are particularly apparent in the relatively few studies investigating OCBs in sales forces. The authors argue that some specific characteristics of the selling job and related tasks make the analysis of the practice of these behaviors in the sales context particularly interesting. Design/methodology/approach – The authors explore which OCBs salespeople engage in, and analyze the perceived consequences of such behaviors using means-end theory and the laddering technique. They apply means-end theory and the laddering technique to interview a sample of salespersons from three companies operating in different business-to-business settings. Findings – The end result of the empirical analysis is the hierarchical value map showing a set of linkages among OCBs and their perceived consequences. In the perceptions of salespeople, OCBs play a strong utilitarian role in that they facilitate personal goal attainment. In salespeople’s minds, there are no relevant trade-offs between OCBs and task-performance as long as the former can be used to improve the latter. For salespeople, the path from OCBs to performance may vary, depending on whether the performance in question is organizational, individual or customer-focused. Finally, some OCBs apparently contribute to creating customer trust in the salesperson. Research limitations/implications – The findings add some interesting insights to the discussion regarding some controversies in OCBs literature, especially the interplay of contextual performance and task performance. Practical implications – Various types of OCBs can be encouraged through different managerial interventions. As an example, altruism can be fostered by appropriate recruiting criteria (e.g. using “attitude toward teamwork” as a key personnel selection factor), and by training initiatives and leadership style. Altruism can also be stimulated by an adequately designed organizational structure (e.g. team-based) as well as by adopting appropriate integration mechanisms that facilitate interpersonal and interfunctional cooperation. Sales managers can foster some OCBs by promoting knowledge sharing and reciprocal learning among members of the sales team, and by emphasizing the positive consequences of OCBs in all communication with salespeople. Originality/value – Findings from this study challenge some widespread assumptions about OCBs in general. In fact, most of the literature holds that OCBs are an example of prosocial behaviors. Actually, the findings suggest that in the specific case of salespeople, OCBs are ultimately self-directed, for the most part.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document