Whose Ethics? Making Reproductive Ethics More Inclusive and Just

Janus Head ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 17 (1) ◽  
pp. 93-122
Author(s):  
Sonya Charles ◽  

As the field of assisted-reproductive technology progresses, bioethicists continue to debate whether and how the availability of this technology creates new moral duties for parents-to-be. It is rare for these debates to seriously engage with questions related to race and class. Camisha Russell asks us to move race from the margins to the center of our discussions of reproductive ethics. She argues that this shift can work as a kind of corrective that will lead to better theory. In this paper, I build on Russell’s work by considering two proposals related to prenatal genetic diagnosis [PGD] that received a lot of attention and debate—Julian Savulescu and Guy Kahane’s argument in favor of a “principle of procreative beneficence” and Janet Malak and Judith Daar’s argument in favor of a legal duty, in certain cases, to use PGD. My analysis of each of these arguments shows how a lack of diverse viewpoints leads to bad theory. I end the paper by showing how including a diversity of perspectives shifts our focus from rights to justice.

Author(s):  
Bamgboye M Afolabi ◽  
Abayomi B Ajayi ◽  
Tola Ajayi ◽  
Victor D Ajayi ◽  
Ifeoluwa Oyetunji ◽  
...  

Introduction: COVID-19 pandemic has taken the world by storm and consequently, various reproductive medicine societies had since issued guidelines based on best judgement for the safety of IVF patients and attending health staffs Objective: The objective of this study was to assess the opinions of IVF staff in sub-Sahara Africa on the awareness of COVID-19 on Assisted Reproductive Technology. The study also evaluated some of the measures that can mitigate the effects of the virus in IVF clinics. Methodology: Different cadres of staff at Nordica Fertility Center (NFC) in Lagos, Nigeria were interviewed. Those interviewed included the Medical Director, Clinicians/Gynecologists, Clinic Manager, Nurses, Embryologists, Counsellor, Business Developing Unit, Client Liaison Officers and Accounts Officer. Their responses were collated, and the key points were documented. Each staff in face mask was visited by one interviewer who observed all government-recommended sanitary precautions including wearing a facemask and maintaining social distance between her and the interviewee. Result: The response of the MD on the fate of IVF clinic in Africa within the next 6 months to 1 year of the Covid-19 pandemic was that the overall economy is a major determinant of the ability of clients to pay for IVF services. Infertile women would still want to have children but “how would they pay for the services?” since ART is not subsidized by the government but mostly paid as out-of-pocket expense in this part of the world. The main points were that IVF clinics are not immune to the economy and vaccine may or may not favor IVF, reasons being; The virus is about 5 months old hence still much to be discovered There is no solid evidence that the virus affects reproduction No evidence of mother-to-child transmission and The virus can survive in cold environment therefore, it could survive cryopreservation. The embryologist was of the opinion that IVF clinics in Africa need to understand the virus more to decide whether: Attend to COVID-19 patients or not and if so, how best to care for them Better prepare modalities of cryopreservation such as Appropriate equipment Batching gametes together with HIV or Hepatitis patients In same or separate equipment and Getting special cryo-tanks for Covid-19 patients. Embryologist agreed that clinics will be able to perform other adjunct fertility treatment such as Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD), dependent on clinics’ ability to have separate equipment for Covid19-positive and negative patients. Conclusion: Africa is not left behind in experiencing the effects of COVID-19 and ART, for which concerns for the survival of privately owned clinics to ensure and safeguard the health and safety of patients, staff and the unborn babies are expressed. As of now, no-one is sure of patients that are symptomatic and those not symptomatic, as testing in the country, just like in most parts of the world, are still inadequate. When a vaccine is available, it may be mandatory for every IVF patient to get a shot. The main points of other cadres of staff are discussed.


2012 ◽  
Vol 61 (3) ◽  
pp. 75-82
Author(s):  
Julija Artemevna Loginova ◽  
Olga Gavrilovna Chiryaeva

Preimplantation genetic diagnosis was first reported 20 years ago. During this time the range of possibilities of assisted reproductive technology has expanded and the possibility of molecular diagnosis of single cells greatly increased. Preimplantation diagnosis has evolved from an experimental procedure to an efficient form of Prenatal Diagnosis, which broadened the indications for Prenatal Diagnosis and can be applied at the earliest stage. This review shows the current state of preimplantation genetic diagnosis and describes its capabilities


2003 ◽  
Vol 80 (2) ◽  
pp. 467-468 ◽  
Author(s):  
Lawrence Werlin ◽  
Ingrid Rodi ◽  
Alan DeCherney ◽  
Ellen Marello ◽  
David Hill ◽  
...  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document