Chapter 9: Challenging the myth of indigenous peoples’ ‘last stand’ in Canada and Australia: public discourse and the conditions of silence

2017 ◽  
pp. 171-192
Author(s):  
Hanne Veber

culture - modern images and conscious identities Over recent years public discourse in the West has re-focused the question of indigenous peoples from one where indigenous groups were seen primarily as disadvantaged, marginalized populations to a perspective on indigenous groups as cultures. However, this public discourse embraces its objects through, often distorting, images - in the Baudrillardian sense of a hyperreality of flowing signs. Paradoxically, indigenous peoples then need to adopt to Western images of „their” culture and make them look real, in order to retain political and financial support from the West. Support, gained in this contradictory way, tums into a new mechanism for social control by the West over the indigenous Rest. It is argued that the unfinished business of reimagining the concept of culture often has tended (so far) to merrily subsistute the postmodem consumerist lifestyle notion of culture for a theoretical formulation of a more general applicability. While the former sees culture as a domain of self-creation seemingly liberated from the constraints of social and political structures, the latter is starting to equate culture with a human capacity for empowerment that arises as an aspect of collective social interaction within given political-economic contexts and historical conjunctures. The author ends by calling on the well-meaning advocates who work with and for indigenous peoples to acknowledge that it is not culture but persistent structures of colonialism, asymmetrical power relations, and forces of an overtly non-cultural character such as economical exploitation and violent repression that continue to form the conditioning contexts of the indigenous situation.


2020 ◽  
Vol 22 (7) ◽  
pp. 1206-1226
Author(s):  
Carrie Karsgaard ◽  
Maggie MacDonald

Through mainstream discourses that infuse all components of society, settler superiority is naturalized in Canada. This process occurs at the expense of Indigenous peoples who continue to be displaced from the land, which is conceptualized as a ‘resource’. Despite the seemingly static nature of settler colonialism, its hegemony is both contested and reinforced through the participatory social space of Instagram. Though it is primarily known for its aesthetic and visual communication properties, Instagram’s visuality contributes substantially to public discourse, enabling resistant and political expressions around specific issues. Using data collected from Instagram, this article maps the social life of Canada’s controversial Trans Mountain pipeline issue, as it develops under medium-specific affordances. Around the Trans Mountain pipeline issue, hashtags and imagery mutually inform one another on Instagram, connecting highly located and temporal experiences with national policies, as users performatively challenge and reinforce social relations as they exist under settler colonialism.


Author(s):  
Anna Roosvall ◽  
Matthew Tegelberg

Climate change has universal, global implications and uneven, particular local effects. Examining how this complex phenomenon is understood in public discourse calls for the merging of theorizing on geography, justice, nature and the mediation of environmental protest. This article combines these strands to discuss relationships between peoples, places, politics, nature and the media in terms of climate justice. Empirical examples are drawn from interviews conducted with indigenous activists and observations of press events organized by indigenous groups during a U.N. climate summit. We argue that the “misframing” of indigenous peoples at international climate summits underlines the necessity to integrate the perspectives of marginalized, transnational groups and their growing demands for climate justice into future media research on climate change, and the need for a re-framing of the mediation of climate change.


2019 ◽  
Vol 60 (4) ◽  
pp. 265-280
Author(s):  
Jeffrey Ansloos ◽  
Suzanne Stewart ◽  
Karlee Fellner ◽  
Alanaise Goodwill ◽  
Holly Graham ◽  
...  

2010 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mona Lisa Saloy ◽  
Cheryl Ajirotutu ◽  
Harry Vanodenallen
Keyword(s):  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document