Leaf size and shape, long used to differentiate taxa in Haenianthus, were found to be less useful than previously believed. Nevertheless, two species can be recognized on the basis of leaf shape, H. incrassatus and H. salicifolius. The former species has long petioles, attenuate leaf bases, and thin laminas and is endemic to cloud forests of Jamaica. The latter species, with short petioles, acute to acuminate leaf bases, and thick laminas, has two varieties, H. salicifolius var. salicifolius of Cuba and Haiti, and H. salicifolius var. obovatus of Cuba, Hispaniola, and Puerto Rico. Key words: Caribbean, Haenianthus, morphometric analysis, Oleaceae.