Incompatibility of Published ac Magnetic Susceptibility of a Room Temperature Superconductor with Measured Raw Data

Room temperature superconductivity has recently been reported for a carbonaceous sulfur hydride (CSH) under high pressure by Snider et al [1]. The paper reports sharp drops in magnetic susceptibility as a function of temperature for five different pressures, that are interpreted as signaling a superconducting transition. Here I question the validity and faithfulness of the magnetic susceptibility data presented in the paper by comparison with the measured raw data reported by two of the authors of ref. [2]. This invalidates the assertion of the paper [1] that the susceptibility measurements support the case for superconductivity in this compound.

Incompatibility of Published ac Magnetic Susceptibility of a Room Temperature Superconductor with Measured Raw Data

Room temperature superconductivity has recently been reported for a carbonaceous sulfur hydride (CSH) under high pressure by Snider et al [1]. The paper reports sharp drops in magnetic susceptibility as a function of temperature for five different pressures, that are interpreted as signaling a superconducting transition. Here I question the validity and faithfulness of the magnetic susceptibility data presented in the paper by comparison with the measured raw data reported by two of the authors of ref. [2]. This casts doubt on the assertion of the paper [1] that the susceptibility measurements support the case for superconductivity in this compound.

Potential Room Temperature Superconductivity in Clathrate Lanthanide/Actinides Octadechydrides at Extreme Pressures

Atomic metallic hydrogen (AMH) hosting high-temperature superconductivity has long been considered a holy grail in condensed matter physics and attracted great interest, but attempts to produce AMH remain in intense exploration and debate. Meanwhile, hydrogen-rich compounds known as superhydrides offer a promising route toward creating AMH-like state and property, as showcased by the recent prediction and ensuing synthesis of LaH10 that hosts extraordinary superconducting critical temperatures (Tc) of 250-260 K at 170-190 GPa. Here we show via advanced crystal structure search a series of hydrogen-superrich clathrate compounds MH18 (M: rare-earth/actinide metals) comprising H36-cage networks, which are predicted to host Tc up to 329 K at 350 GPa. An in-depth examination of these extreme superhydrides offers key insights for elucidating and further exploring ultimate phonon-mediated superconductivity in a broad class of AMH-like materials.

Superconductivity up to 243 K in the yttrium-hydrogen system under high pressure

The discovery of superconducting H3S with a critical temperature Tc∼200 K opened a door to room temperature superconductivity and stimulated further extensive studies of hydrogen-rich compounds stabilized by high pressure. Here, we report a comprehensive study of the yttrium-hydrogen system with the highest predicted Tcs among binary compounds and discuss the contradictions between different theoretical calculations and experimental data. We synthesized yttrium hydrides with the compositions of YH3, YH4, YH6 and YH9 in a diamond anvil cell and studied their crystal structures, electrical and magnetic transport properties, and isotopic effects. We found superconductivity in the Im-3m YH6 and P63/mmc YH9 phases with maximal Tcs of ∼220 K at 183 GPa and ∼243 K at 201 GPa, respectively. Fm-3m YH10 with the highest predicted Tc > 300 K was not observed in our experiments, and instead, YH9 was found to be the hydrogen-richest yttrium hydride in the studied pressure and temperature range up to record 410 GPa and 2250 K.